Skip to main content
AAHPM Logo
Login
  • Join/Renew
  • Blog
  • Contact
Menu Search Account
  • Membership
    • Join/Renew
      • Member Benefits
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
    • Member Center
    • Getting Involved
    • Communities
      • SIG Instructions
      • Join a SIG
      • Member Councils
    • Mentoring
    • FAAHPM
      • Current Fellows
  • Education & Practice
    • Writing Instructional Objectives
    • Meetings
      • Annual Assembly
        • Registration
        • Back to Meetings
        • Assembly Home
        • About the Assembly
          • Why Attend
        • Educational Sessions
          • Plenaries
        • Plan Your Experience
        • CE and MOC
        • Exhibits & Advertising
        • Call for Case and Scholar Posters
        • Assembly FAQs
        • Call for Papers and Posters
          • Topics for Assembly
        • Business Meeting
      • Leadership Forum: Ascend
      • State of the Science
      • State of the Science
        • Back to Meetings
        • Home
      • Board Review Course
        • Back to Meetings
        • Home
        • Schedule
      • Calendar
      • Intensive Board Review Course 2018 Recordings
      • IBRC18 - Additional Management Strategies for Cancer Related Symptoms
      • IBRC18 - Approaches to Care, including Hospice/Medicare
      • IBRC18 - Assessment and Care of the Dying Patient
      • IBRC18 - Communication and Teamwork
      • IBRC18 - Depression/Anxiety & Other Mood Disorders
      • IBRC18 - Ethical and Legal Decision Making
      • IBRC18 - Grief and Bereavement and Spiritual Care
      • IBRC18 - High Yield Pediatrics for the Boards
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – GI
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – Respiratory
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management: Pot-Pourri
      • IBRC18 - Pain Management Overview
      • IBRC18 - Palliative Sedation/Physician-Assisted Dying/Discontinuation of Technological Support
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (1)
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (2)
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (3)
      • IBRC18 - Prognostication
      • IBRC18 - Special Topics in Pain Management
      • IBRC18 - Symptom Potpourri
      • IBRC18 - Taking the Test Like a Pro
      • IBRC18 - Urgent Medical Conditions
    • Publications
      • JPSM
        • Members JPSM
      • PC-FACS
        • Members - PC-FACS
      • Quarterly
        • Members Quarterly Full Access
          • Summer 14 President's Message
          • Summer 14 Academy News
          • Summer 14 Advocacy Updates
          • summer 14 Art of Caring
          • Summer 14 Clinical Pearls
          • Summer 14 Progress Report
          • summer 14 communities
          • summer 14 Assembly
          • Fall14 Academy News
          • Fall 14 Advocacy Update
          • Fall 14 Annual Assembly
          • Fall 14 Art of Caring
          • Fall 14 Clinical Pearls
          • Fall 14 Feature
          • Fall 14 HMDCB
          • Fall 14 President
          • Fall 14 Progress
          • Winter 14 Clinical Pearls
          • Winter 14 Leaders
          • Winter 14 AAHPM News
          • Winter 14 Advocacy Update
          • Winter 14 Art of Caring
          • Winter 14 Board of Directors
          • Winter 14 Feature
          • Winter 14 HMDCB Exam
          • Winter 14 Paper Sessions
          • Winter 14 President's Message
          • Winter 14 Progress Report
          • Spring 15 President's Message
          • Spring 15 Clinical Pearls
          • Spring 15 Advocacy Update
          • Spring 15 Art of Caring
          • Spring 15 Feature
          • Spring 15 HMDCB Certification
          • Spring 15 Communities Update
          • Spring 15 Shaping the Future
          • Spring 15 AAHPM News
          • Summer 15 AAHPM News
          • Summer 14 Feature
          • Summer 15 AAHPM Summer Institute
          • Summer 15 Advocacy Update
          • Summer 15 Annual Assembly
          • Summer 15 Art of Caring
          • Summer 15 Clinical Pearls
          • Summer 15 Communities Update
          • Summer 15 Feature
          • Summer 15 HMDCB Exam
          • Summer 15 Meet Joe Rotella
          • Summer 15 President's Message
          • Summer 15 Quarterly Progress Report
          • Fall 15 Feature
          • Fall 15 AAHPM News
          • Fall 15 Annual Assembly
          • Fall 15 President's Message
          • Fall 15 Advocacy Update
          • Fall 15 Clinical Pearls
          • Fall 15 Art of Caring
          • Fall 15 Quarterly Progress Report
          • Fall 15 HMDCB Certification
          • Winter 15 AAHPM News
          • Winter 15 Advocacy Update
          • Winter 15 Annual Assembly
          • Winter 15 Art of Caring
          • Winter 15 Clinical Pearls
          • Winter 15 Feature
          • Winter 15 HMDCB Certification
          • Winter 15 President's Message
          • Spring 2016 Feature
          • Spring 2016 President's Message
          • Spring 2016 Clinical Pearls
          • Spring 2016 Art of Caring
          • Spring 2016 Ethics
          • Spring 2016 Communities Update
          • Spring 2016 Quarterly Progress Report
          • Spring 2016 AAHPM News
          • Summer 16 AAHPM News
          • Summer 16 Advocacy Update
          • Summer 16 Art of Caring
          • Summer 16 Assembly Recap
          • Summer 16 Clinical Pearls
          • Summer 16 Communities Update
          • Summer 16 Death Cafe
          • Summer 16 Feature
          • Summer 16 HMDCB Update
          • Summer 16 President's Message
          • Summer 16 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 16 AAHPM News
        • Fall 16 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 16 Art of Caring
        • Fall 16 Assembly Promo
        • Fall 16 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 16 Ethics
        • Fall 16 Feature
        • Fall 16 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 16 President's Message
        • Fall 16 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 16 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 16 AAHPM News
        • Winter 16 Art of Caring
        • Winter 16 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 16 Ethics
        • Winter 16 Feature
        • Winter 16 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 16 President's Message
        • Winter 16 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 16 Assembly Paper Sessions
        • Spring 17 AAHPM News
        • Spring 17 Art of Caring
        • Spring 17 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 17 Feature
        • Spring 17 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 17 President's Message
        • Spring 17 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 17 Stay Certified
        • Summer 17 AAHPM News
        • Summer 17 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 17 Art of Caring
        • Summer 17 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 17 Ethics
        • Summer 17 Feature
        • Summer 17 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 17 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 17 President's Message
        • Summer 17 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 17 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 17 President's Message
        • Fall 17 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 17 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 17 Feature
        • Fall 17 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 17 Art of Caring
        • Fall 17 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 17 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 17 AAHPM News
        • Winter 17 AAHPM News
        • Winter 17 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 17 Art of Caring
        • Winter 17 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 17 Feature
        • Winter 17 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 17 All About Essentials
        • Winter 17 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 17 President's Message
        • Winter 17 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 18 Diversity & Inclusion
        • Spring 18 Feature
        • Spring 18 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 18 Presidents Message
        • Spring 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 18 AAHPM News
        • Spring 18 Art of Caring
        • Summer 18 AAHPM News
        • Summer 18 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 18 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 18 Art of Caring
        • Summer 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 18 Ethics
        • Summer 18 Feature
        • Summer 18 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 18 President's Message
        • Summer 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 18 AAHPM News
        • Fall 18 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 18 Art of Caring
        • Fall 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 18 Diversity & Inclusion
        • Fall 18 Feature
        • Fall 18 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 18 President's Message
        • Fall 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 18 AAHPM News
        • Winter 18 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 18 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 18 Art of Caring
        • Winter 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 18 Ethics
        • Winter 18 Feature
        • Winter 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 18 President's Message
        • Winter 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 18 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 19 Editors Message
        • Spring 19 Meet the President
        • Spring 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 19 Art of Caring
        • Spring 19 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 19 Feature
        • Spring 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 19 Diversity and Inclusion
        • Spring 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 19 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 19 AAHPM News
        • Summer 19 Presidents Message
        • Summer 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 19 Art of Caring
        • Summer 19 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 19 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 19 Feature
        • Summer 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 19 Ethics and the Hidden Curriculum
        • Summer 19 Research or Quality Improvement
        • Summer 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 19 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 19 AAHPM News
        • Fall 19 Presidents Message
        • Fall 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 19 Art of Caring
        • Fall 19 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 19 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 19 Feature
        • Fall 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 19 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 19 Quality Improvement
        • Fall 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 19 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 19 AAHPM News
        • Fall 19 State of the Science
        • Winter 19 Presidents Message
        • Winter 19 Editor's Message
        • Winter 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 19 Art of Caring
        • Winter 19 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 19 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 19 Feature
        • Winter 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 19 State of the Science
        • Winter 19 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 19 AAHPM News
        • Spring 20 Presidents Message
        • Spring 20 Meet the President
        • Spring 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Spring 20 Art of Caring
        • Spring 20 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 20 Feature
        • Spring 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 20 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 20 AAHPM News
        • Summer 20 Presidents Message
        • Summer 20 Meet New AAHPM CEO
        • Summer 20 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 20 State of the Science
        • Summer 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 20 Art of Caring
        • Summer 20 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 20 Feature
        • Summer 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 20 AAHPM News
        • Summer 20 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 20 PCQC Update
        • Fall 20 Presidents Message
        • Fall 20 Art of Caring
        • Fall 20 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 20 Lets Think About it Again
        • Fall 20 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 20 Feature
        • Fall 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 20 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 20 PCQC Update
        • Winter 20 Presidents Message
        • Winter 20 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 20 Lets Think About it Again
        • Winter 20 Art of Caring
        • Winter 20 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 20 Feature
        • Winter 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Winter 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 20 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 20 PCQC Update
        • Winter 20 AAHPM News
      • SmartBriefs
    • Self-Study
      • Board Prep Materials
      • Essentials
      • Primer
      • HPM PASS
      • HPM FAST
        • HPM FAST CME
      • Hospice Products
        • HMD Manual
        • HMD PREP
          • HMD PREP CME
      • Opioid REMS
      • Recordings
      • hpmpasscme
      • HPMQ
      • Opioid Resources
    • Fellowships
      • Competencies
        • Pediatric Competencies
      • Accreditation
      • NRMP Match
      • Grants
        • Ho/Chiang Foundation
      • Hospice Program Toolkit
    • CME
    • Quality
      • Measuring What Matters
      • Quality Reporting
      • Quality Resources
      • Quality Registries
      • Quality Improvement Education
    • Research
      • Research Funding
      • Successful Research Grants
    • COVID-19 Resources
    • COVID hotel
  • Advocacy
    • Stay Informed
    • Take Action
    • Key Issues
      • Opioids
      • Workforce
  • Career Development
    • Jobs
      • Virtual Career Fair
    • Clinical Training
      • Additional Training
    • Leadership Development
      • AAHPM Ascend
        • Leadership Forum Faculty and Facilitators
        • Ascend Schedule
        • Ascend Facilitators
      • AAHPM Elevate
    • Certification
      • Allopathic
      • Hospice
        • HMDCB Research
      • Osteopathic
    • Continuing HPM Certification
    • Workforce Statistics
    • Scholarships
      • Access Fund
      • Leadership Scholars
      • International Physicians
      • Pediatric Scholarship
      • Research Scholars
    • Resilience and Well-being
  • About
    • History
    • Position Statements
      • Access to Palliative Care and Hospice Position Statement
      • Artificial Nutrition Position Statement
      • Research Ethics Position Statement
      • Palliative Sedation Position Statement
      • Physician-Assisted Dying Position Statement
      • Withholding Position Statement
      • Physician Assisted Dying Position Statement Review
      • Physician-Assisted Dying
    • Talking About HPM
      • Advance Directives-Talking HPM
      • Choosing a Hospice Program-Talking HPM
      • Defining HPM-Talking HPM
      • Explaining PAD-Talking HPM
      • Costs-Talking HPM
      • Withdrawing LST-Talking HPM
      • Choosing Wisely
      • Members Talking About HPM
    • Governance
      • Board of Directors
        • Board Only
        • Past Presidents
      • Committees
      • Staff
        • Staff
      • Revised Bylaws
    • Donate
      • AAHPM Giving Circle
    • Awards
      • Visionaries in HPM
      • Emerging Leaders
    • Social Media
  • Store
    • Browse All
    • Books
    • E-Learning
    • Recordings
    • Essentials
  • My Account
  • Username & Password
  • Manage Credit Cards
  • Demographics
  • My Classroom
  • Quarterly Newsletter
  • Pay Open Balances
  • Purchase History
  • Membership Details
  • My Communities
  • My Volunteer History
  • Uploaded Documents
  • Writing Instructional Objectives
  • Meetings
    • Annual Assembly
    • Leadership Forum: Ascend
    • State of the Science
    • State of the Science
    • Board Review Course
    • Calendar
    • Intensive Board Review Course 2018 Recordings
    • IBRC18 - Additional Management Strategies for Cancer Related Symptoms
    • IBRC18 - Approaches to Care, including Hospice/Medicare
    • IBRC18 - Assessment and Care of the Dying Patient
    • IBRC18 - Communication and Teamwork
    • IBRC18 - Depression/Anxiety & Other Mood Disorders
    • IBRC18 - Ethical and Legal Decision Making
    • IBRC18 - Grief and Bereavement and Spiritual Care
    • IBRC18 - High Yield Pediatrics for the Boards
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – GI
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – Respiratory
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management: Pot-Pourri
    • IBRC18 - Pain Management Overview
    • IBRC18 - Palliative Sedation/Physician-Assisted Dying/Discontinuation of Technological Support
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (1)
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (2)
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (3)
    • IBRC18 - Prognostication
    • IBRC18 - Special Topics in Pain Management
    • IBRC18 - Symptom Potpourri
    • IBRC18 - Taking the Test Like a Pro
    • IBRC18 - Urgent Medical Conditions
  • Publications
    • JPSM
    • PC-FACS
    • Quarterly
    • SmartBriefs
  • Self-Study
    • Board Prep Materials
    • Essentials
    • Primer
    • HPM PASS
    • HPM FAST
    • Hospice Products
    • Opioid REMS
    • Recordings
    • hpmpasscme
    • HPMQ
    • Opioid Resources
  • Fellowships
    • Competencies
    • Accreditation
    • NRMP Match
    • Grants
    • Hospice Program Toolkit
  • CME
  • Quality
    • Measuring What Matters
    • Quality Reporting
    • Quality Resources
    • Quality Registries
    • Quality Improvement Education
  • Research
    • Research Funding
    • Successful Research Grants
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • COVID hotel

Let's Think About It Again

Chemotherapy for a Patient with SUD

Case Study

Mr. Y. is a 45-year-old male who recently was diagnosed with extensive-stage small cell lung cancer (SCLC) and struggles with severe and ongoing substance use disorder (SUD) and regularly takes heroin. He presented to his oncologist, who offered him aggressive chemotherapy with the hope of stabilizing the terminal disease, potentially for months. The oncologist also referred Mr. Y. to an outpatient Suboxone® clinic to address his ongoing SUD.

The patient agreed to but did not follow the plan as intended, and later presented to an emergency department after a heroin overdose. The patient was revived with naloxone and fully recovered.

Mr. Y. comes to the outpatient oncology clinic a few days later for follow-up. He would like to proceed with chemotherapy but not taking Suboxone and states he can manage his heroin use on his own. He also has a history of longstanding depression and recently became homeless after his son told him to move out following the overdose episode. Other members of the interdisciplinary care team have been consulted about the many issues affecting Mr. Y. and his care, such as the need for safe housing.

Should Mr. Y. be offered chemotherapy if he does not receive appropriate care for his ongoing SUD?

Point: Monika Holbein, MD, assistant professor of medicine, West Virginia University

SCLC is an extremely aggressive cancer that is highly susceptible to the chemotherapy regimen of etoposide and carboplatin. In addition, there is a newly approved immunotherapy that has shown benefit for a subset of patients that could be considered. Given that his prognosis would be less than 1 month without any treatment, Mr. Y. should start treatment immediately.

His SUD should be considered a complicating factor to treatment and not an absolute counter indication. Mr. Y. has not started treatment, so there is no knowledge of his motivation to complete treatment. He also has not yet had the opportunity to benefit from the multidisciplinary nature of cancer treatment, including, but not limited to, social work, oncology, nutrition, palliative care, and radiation oncology.

Unless Mr. Y. is actively engaged in SUD treatment, he likely will continue to use heroin. Using precautions at this point, such as a naloxone rescue inhaler with extensive education for Mr. Y. and his close contacts, will help mitigate the risk of overdose. It is important to practice awareness when prescribing him medications, avoiding benzodiazepines and opioids.

Mr. Y. does not have stable housing after his son asked him to leave. We do not have more information on his support system. Family relationships frequently are complicated when SUD is involved. We need more information on how to best support this family and how to approach Mr. Y.'s healthcare needs prior to passing judgment. There are housing opportunities that may be better suited to this patient's current needs than his son's home.

The ethical considerations of not treating a patient because of a medical condition remain. If Mr. Y. had uncontrolled type 2 diabetes, the question of whether to treat the cancer would not arise. There is an obligation to offer treatment for cancer in Mr. Y. because it would improve his quality of life as well as his quantity.

Counterpoint: Ellen Fulp, PharmD MSPC BCGP, director of pharmacy education at AvaCare, Inc.

Respecting autonomy is a cornerstone of supportive care for seriously ill patients. However, respecting patient preferences does not excuse clinicians from guiding shared decision making and weighing the risks and benefits of treatment options.

Extensive-stage SCLC initially is treated with a platinum-etoposide–based chemotherapy regimen. Commonly experienced adverse effects include nausea, oral mucositis, decreased immune function, pain, neurotoxicity, extravasation, and end organ damage.

Anticipated adverse effects associated with chemotherapy will require additional therapies, which, like chemotherapy, require that the treatment plan be followed to be successful. The long- and short-term effects of continued heroin use compound chemotherapy's adverse effects. Moreover, continued heroin use may prevent Mr. Y. from successfully completing chemotherapy and the medication plan used to offset chemotherapy-induced adverse effects. Mr. Y. displays behaviors associated with self-titration, which could be deadly if he progresses to oral chemotherapy, not to mention oral opioid therapy. Without lifestyle changes and social support at home, Mr. Y. is not likely to tolerate or be able to follow a chemotherapy regimen as prescribed.

Eliminating chemotherapy as part of Mr. Y.'s treatment initially seems cruel. However, as clinicians, it is our professional responsibility to prescribe and design regimens that offer relief of suffering without undue harms and risks. Allowing Mr. Y. to select and receive chemotherapy under the present conditions goes against not only our professional obligations, but also the very principles of palliative care.

Ethically, we must recommend against chemotherapy in this case. It is more likely to cause harm without transient or sustained benefits. As noted with certain other life-prolonging interventions, including bariatric surgery and organ transplant, patients who do not make lifestyle modifications are at high risk for relapse and often do not follow the treatment plan as prescribed.

For justice to be preserved, Mr. Y. should receive the same care we offer every patient we serve. This individualized care must include working together and considering patient circumstances to balance risks with expected outcomes based on patient and medication characteristics. Although rational prescribing dictates that chemotherapy is not appropriate here, palliative care, focusing on symptom resolution and the relief of suffering, always is appropriate for patients diagnosed with extensive-stage SCLC.

The purpose of this column is to encourage discussion about the many challenges presented to clinicians in hospice and palliative care. The viewpoints presented here do not necessarily represent a comprehensive analysis of the issue or the opinions of the authors or AAHPM.

We want to hear from you. Read the Quarterly Editorial Board's response to a letter to the editor and continue this discussion online at connect.aahpm.org.


Read the next article or go to the table of contents.

Essential Practices in Hospice and Palliative Medicine

This newly updated and rebranded comprehensive self-study provides a critical foundation for those who want to incorporate principles of hospice and palliative medicine into their daily lives.

Learn More

Quick Links

  • Job Mart
  • JPSM
  • CME/CE Certificates
  • Purchased Downloads
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

For Exhibitors and Advertisers

  • Commercial Support
  • Exhibiting and Advertising
  • Mailing Labels

For Students and Residents

  • Membership
  • Careers
  • Fellowships
  • Publications
Facebook Twitter Linked In Visit our patient website: PalliativeDoctors.org

AAHPM Logo

8735 West Higgins Road, Suite 300 Chicago, IL 60631

Phone 847-375-4712 Fax 847-375-6475 E-mail info@aahpm.org

Copyright © American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine