Skip to main content
AAHPM Logo
Login
  • Join/Renew
  • Donate
  • Blog
  • Contact
Menu Search Account
  • Membership
    • Join/Renew
      • Member Benefits
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
      • DEI Resources
    • Member Center
    • Getting Involved
    • Communities
      • SIG Instructions
      • Join a SIG
      • Member Councils
    • Mentoring
    • FAAHPM
      • Current Fellows
  • Education & Practice
    • Writing Instructional Objectives
    • Meetings
      • Leadership Forum: Ascend
      • Annual Assembly
        • Back to Meetings
        • Assembly Home
        • About the Assembly
          • Why Attend
        • Registration
        • Special Events
        • Educational Sessions
          • Keynotes
          • Wednesday
          • Thursday
          • Friday
          • Saturday
        • Plan Your Experience
        • CE and MOC
        • Summer Call for Abstracts
        • Fall Call for Abstracts
        • Assembly FAQs
        • Business Meeting
        • Health and Safety
        • Exhibits & Advertising
      • State of the Science
      • State of the Science
        • Back to Meetings
        • State of the Science Home
        • Plan Your Experience
        • Schedule and Pricing
        • SOTS FAQ
        • Virtual State of the Science
      • Intensive Review Course
        • Back to Meetings
        • Home
        • Schedule
        • Plan Your Trip
      • Advanced Course in Pain
        • Back to Meetings
        • Home
        • Plan Your Trip
      • Intensive Board Review Course 2018 Recordings
      • IBRC18 - Additional Management Strategies for Cancer Related Symptoms
      • IBRC18 - Approaches to Care, including Hospice/Medicare
      • IBRC18 - Assessment and Care of the Dying Patient
      • IBRC18 - Communication and Teamwork
      • IBRC18 - Depression/Anxiety & Other Mood Disorders
      • IBRC18 - Ethical and Legal Decision Making
      • IBRC18 - Grief and Bereavement and Spiritual Care
      • IBRC18 - High Yield Pediatrics for the Boards
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – GI
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – Respiratory
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management: Pot-Pourri
      • IBRC18 - Pain Management Overview
      • IBRC18 - Palliative Sedation/Physician-Assisted Dying/Discontinuation of Technological Support
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (1)
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (2)
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (3)
      • IBRC18 - Prognostication
      • IBRC18 - Special Topics in Pain Management
      • IBRC18 - Symptom Potpourri
      • IBRC18 - Taking the Test Like a Pro
      • IBRC18 - Urgent Medical Conditions
    • Publications
      • JPSM
        • Members JPSM
      • PC-FACS
        • Members - PC-FACS
      • Quarterly
        • Members Quarterly Full Access
        • Spring 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 18 Diversity & Inclusion
        • Spring 18 Feature
        • Spring 18 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 18 Presidents Message
        • Spring 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 18 AAHPM News
        • Spring 18 Art of Caring
        • Summer 18 AAHPM News
        • Summer 18 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 18 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 18 Art of Caring
        • Summer 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 18 Ethics
        • Summer 18 Feature
        • Summer 18 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 18 President's Message
        • Summer 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 18 AAHPM News
        • Fall 18 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 18 Art of Caring
        • Fall 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 18 Diversity & Inclusion
        • Fall 18 Feature
        • Fall 18 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 18 President's Message
        • Fall 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 18 AAHPM News
        • Winter 18 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 18 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 18 Art of Caring
        • Winter 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 18 Ethics
        • Winter 18 Feature
        • Winter 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 18 President's Message
        • Winter 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 18 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 19 Editors Message
        • Spring 19 Meet the President
        • Spring 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 19 Art of Caring
        • Spring 19 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 19 Feature
        • Spring 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 19 Diversity and Inclusion
        • Spring 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 19 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 19 AAHPM News
        • Summer 19 Presidents Message
        • Summer 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 19 Art of Caring
        • Summer 19 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 19 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 19 Feature
        • Summer 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 19 Ethics and the Hidden Curriculum
        • Summer 19 Research or Quality Improvement
        • Summer 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 19 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 19 AAHPM News
        • Fall 19 Presidents Message
        • Fall 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 19 Art of Caring
        • Fall 19 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 19 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 19 Feature
        • Fall 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 19 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 19 Quality Improvement
        • Fall 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 19 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 19 AAHPM News
        • Fall 19 State of the Science
        • Winter 19 Presidents Message
        • Winter 19 Editor's Message
        • Winter 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 19 Art of Caring
        • Winter 19 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 19 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 19 Feature
        • Winter 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 19 State of the Science
        • Winter 19 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 19 AAHPM News
        • Spring 20 Presidents Message
        • Spring 20 Meet the President
        • Spring 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Spring 20 Art of Caring
        • Spring 20 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 20 Feature
        • Spring 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 20 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 20 AAHPM News
        • Summer 20 Presidents Message
        • Summer 20 Meet New AAHPM CEO
        • Summer 20 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 20 State of the Science
        • Summer 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 20 Art of Caring
        • Summer 20 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 20 Feature
        • Summer 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 20 AAHPM News
        • Summer 20 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 20 PCQC Update
        • Fall 20 Presidents Message
        • Fall 20 Art of Caring
        • Fall 20 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 20 Lets Think About it Again
        • Fall 20 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 20 Feature
        • Fall 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 20 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 20 PCQC Update
        • Winter 20 Presidents Message
        • Winter 20 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 20 Lets Think About it Again
        • Winter 20 Art of Caring
        • Winter 20 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 20 Feature
        • Winter 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Winter 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 20 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 20 PCQC Update
        • Winter 20 AAHPM News
        • Spring 21 A Message from the CEO
        • Spring 21 Meet the President
        • Spring 21 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 21 Art of Caring
        • Spring 21 Interview with AAFP President
        • Spring 21 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 21 Feature
        • Spring 21 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 21 Lets Think About it Again
        • Spring 21 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Spring 21 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 21 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 21 PCQC Update
        • Spring 21 AAHPM News
        • Summer 21 A Message from the President
        • Summer 21 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 21 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 21 Art of Caring
        • Summer 21 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 21 Feature
        • Summer 21 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 21 Lets Think About it Again
        • Summer 21 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 21 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 21 PCQC Update
        • Summer 21 AAHPM News
        • Fall 21 A Message from the President
        • Fall 21 State of Science
        • Fall 21 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 21 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 21 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 21 Feature
        • Fall 21 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 21 Lets Think About it Again
        • Fall 21 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 21 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 21 Art of Caring
        • Fall 21 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 21 PCQC Update
        • Winter 21 A Message from the President
        • Winter 21 The Bridge Builder
        • Winter 21 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 21 Art of Caring
        • Winter 21 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 21 Feature
        • Winter 21 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 21 Lets Think About it Again
        • Winter 21 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 21 Partner Updates
        • Winter 21 AAHPM News
        • Spring 22 Meet the President
        • Spring 22 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 22 Art of Caring
        • Spring 22 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 22 Feature
        • Spring 22 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 22 Lets Think About It Again
        • Spring 22 DEI LAB
        • Spring 22 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 22 AAHPM Partner Update
        • Spring 22 AAHPM News
        • AAHPM Quarterly: Spring 2022 (Full Issue)
        • Summer 22 A Message from the President
        • Summer 22 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 22 Art of Caring
        • Summer 22 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 22 Feature
        • Summer 22 DEI LAB
        • Summer 22 Quarterly Progress Report
        • AAHPM Quarterly: Summer 2022 (Full Issue)
      • SmartBriefs
    • AAHPM Learn
      • Interactive Activities
    • Self-Study
      • Board Prep Materials
      • Essentials
      • Primer
      • HPM PASS
      • HPM FAST
        • HPM FAST CME
      • Hospice Products
        • HMD Manual
        • HMD PREP
      • Opioid REMS
      • hpmpasscme
      • Opioid Resources
    • Fellowships
      • Competencies
        • Pediatric Competencies
      • Accreditation
      • NRMP Match
      • Grants
        • Ho/Chiang Foundation
      • Hospice Program Toolkit
      • CBME Recordings
    • CME
    • Quality
      • Measuring What Matters
      • Quality Reporting
      • Quality Resources
      • Quality Registries
      • Quality Improvement Education
    • Research
      • Research Funding
      • Successful Research Grants
    • COVID-19 Resources
    • COVID hotel
  • Advocacy
    • Stay Informed
    • Take Action
    • Key Issues
      • Opioids
      • Workforce
  • Career Development
    • Jobs
      • Virtual Career Fair
    • Clinical Training
      • Additional Training
    • Leadership Development
      • AAHPM Ascend
        • Leadership Forum Faculty and Facilitators
        • Ascend Schedule
        • Ascend Facilitators
    • Certification
      • Allopathic
      • Hospice
        • HMDCB Research
      • Osteopathic
    • Continuing HPM Certification
    • Workforce Statistics
    • Scholarships
      • Access Fund
      • Leadership Scholars
      • International Physicians
      • Pediatric Scholarship
      • Research Scholars
      • Next Gen Scholars
    • Resilience and Well-being
  • About
    • History
    • Position Statements
      • Access to Palliative Care and Hospice Position Statement
      • Artificial Nutrition Position Statement
      • Research Ethics Position Statement
      • Palliative Sedation Position Statement
      • Physician-Assisted Dying Position Statement
      • Withholding Position Statement
      • Physician Assisted Dying Position Statement Review
      • Physician-Assisted Dying
    • Talking About HPM
      • Advance Directives-Talking HPM
      • Choosing a Hospice Program-Talking HPM
      • Defining HPM-Talking HPM
      • Explaining PAD-Talking HPM
      • Costs-Talking HPM
      • Withdrawing LST-Talking HPM
      • Choosing Wisely
      • Members Talking About HPM
    • Governance
      • Board of Directors
        • Board Only
        • Past Presidents
      • Committees
      • Staff
        • Staff
      • Call for Nominations
      • Revised Bylaws
    • Giving Center
      • Reasons to Give
      • AAHPM Giving Circle
      • Year End Donations
      • Giving Tuesday Donations
      • Bogetz Educational Fund
      • Donation Form
      • Donation FAQ
    • Awards
      • Visionaries in HPM
      • Emerging Leaders
    • Social Media
  • AAHPM Learn
    • Browse All
    • Books
    • Core Content
    • Self-Study
    • Essentials
  • Legislative Action Center
  • My Account
  • Username & Password
  • Manage Credit Cards
  • Demographics
  • My Classroom
  • Quarterly Newsletter
  • Pay Open Balances
  • Purchase History
  • Membership Details
  • My Communities
  • My Volunteer History
  • Uploaded Documents
  • Writing Instructional Objectives
  • Meetings
    • Leadership Forum: Ascend
    • Annual Assembly
    • State of the Science
    • State of the Science
    • Intensive Review Course
    • Advanced Course in Pain
    • Intensive Board Review Course 2018 Recordings
    • IBRC18 - Additional Management Strategies for Cancer Related Symptoms
    • IBRC18 - Approaches to Care, including Hospice/Medicare
    • IBRC18 - Assessment and Care of the Dying Patient
    • IBRC18 - Communication and Teamwork
    • IBRC18 - Depression/Anxiety & Other Mood Disorders
    • IBRC18 - Ethical and Legal Decision Making
    • IBRC18 - Grief and Bereavement and Spiritual Care
    • IBRC18 - High Yield Pediatrics for the Boards
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – GI
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – Respiratory
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management: Pot-Pourri
    • IBRC18 - Pain Management Overview
    • IBRC18 - Palliative Sedation/Physician-Assisted Dying/Discontinuation of Technological Support
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (1)
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (2)
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (3)
    • IBRC18 - Prognostication
    • IBRC18 - Special Topics in Pain Management
    • IBRC18 - Symptom Potpourri
    • IBRC18 - Taking the Test Like a Pro
    • IBRC18 - Urgent Medical Conditions
  • Publications
    • JPSM
    • PC-FACS
    • Quarterly
    • SmartBriefs
  • AAHPM Learn
    • Interactive Activities
  • Self-Study
    • Board Prep Materials
    • Essentials
    • Primer
    • HPM PASS
    • HPM FAST
    • Hospice Products
    • Opioid REMS
    • hpmpasscme
    • Opioid Resources
  • Fellowships
    • Competencies
    • Accreditation
    • NRMP Match
    • Grants
    • Hospice Program Toolkit
    • CBME Recordings
  • CME
  • Quality
    • Measuring What Matters
    • Quality Reporting
    • Quality Resources
    • Quality Registries
    • Quality Improvement Education
  • Research
    • Research Funding
    • Successful Research Grants
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • COVID hotel

Feature

feature

Moral Distress, Palliative Care, and the Road to Resilience

Larry Beresford

The COVID-19 pandemic has sorely challenged healthcare professionals, particularly in areas where case numbers surged and challenged capacity. For some, the sheer caseload of severely ill patients, having to witness so many deaths, and their own personal risk of exposure to the virus have caused physical and emotional depletion, exhaustion, suffering, and compassion fatigue—milestones on the road to burnout.

For many, some of this distress may seem like it could or should have been avoided with different systemic, societal, and personal responses, which adds a moral element to the pandemic's mix of case overload, stress, and burnout. Experienced palliative care professionals may have felt that their skills, strategies, and overall orientation to care would have helped them in coping with the pandemic's humanitarian crisis (see AAHPM Quarterly, Spring 2021), but no one was immune to its impact.

The term moral distress describes a type of occupational distress where committed professionals have witnessed or even participated in acts that violated their own sense of right and wrong, deeply held values, and codes of professional ethics. In its earliest days, the term was applied to nurses in a 1984 book by Andrew Jameton,1 though its effects also heavily impact physicians and other clinicians.

The broadness of the concept has resulted in many overlapping ideas around the issues of moral distress, said Betty Ferrell, PhD MSN, director of the division of nursing research and education at City of Hope National Medical Center in Duarte, CA. In many cases, however, "it comes down to finding yourself participating in [something] you are morally opposed to," she said.

This kind of distress has been observed in the care of patients with life-threatening illnesses, for example in intensive care units (ICUs) or in cancer treatment, particularly in cases when a clinician may feel the care they are giving is futile or burdensome. It can be experienced when patients at the end of life are not given accurate information about their prognosis or treatment choices or when families insist on treatments that the professional considers harmful or inconsistent with what the patient might have wanted. Increasing complexity of medical treatments, some of limited benefit; dissonance between what clinicians can do and what they should do; and external pressures, such as from government agencies, payers, and hospitals' throughput demands, also have driven moral distress and injury.

For example, during the pandemic, many health facilities adopted protocols indicating that hospitalized patients were not allowed to have visitors, even when they were dying, to prevent further transmission of the virus to patients, visitors, or staff—but these restrictions often clashed with the fundamental ideologies palliative care and hospice clinicians have worked to support throughout their careers.

"We have fought so hard for the principles of palliative care, such as not letting our patients die alone, supporting the family's experience, and providing respectful care at the end of life. So, it's been hard to see people dying without their family present," Ferrell said. For many, the act of refusing to allow the patients' family to be present runs contrary to their own ethics. "That's moral distress. You may be doing things for eminently sensible reasons, but still, it's painful to see. My colleagues have told me that their greatest distress was watching the distress of their colleagues, such as when they had to hold up a smartphone so that the family could say goodbye via the FaceTime app," she said.

Continuum of Moral Suffering

Moral distress can be seen as belonging to a continuum of moral suffering, said Cynda Rushton, PhD RN, professor of nursing and pediatrics and Bunting Professor of Clinical Ethics at Johns Hopkins University. Rushton has studied moral suffering for many years, and recently edited a book on the topic, Moral Resilience: Transforming Moral Suffering in Healthcare.2 She sees this distress in a broader context of the varieties of anguish professionals experience in response to moral harms.

Some may consider moral distress to be a reflection of some misuse of power, such as pushing professionals to provide care that seems inappropriate or suboptimal. But there may be moral gray zones where responsible professionals disagree.

"We have to accurately diagnose the problem and recognize that this is not the same as burnout," Rushton explained; rather, in the case of moral distress, there is an ethical conflict or dilemma that is causing the distress. "We begin to feel something's not right. That concern can't be relieved. We know what we think we should do, but there are real constraints in the way."

When moral distress becomes severe, unmitigated, unrelenting, and accompanied by feelings of betrayal by our leaders, by the government, by employers, or by society, what can result is moral injury, a term first coined in a military context to describe the aftermath of prolonged or repeated exposure to triggers of moral distress. Moral harms, moral suffering, and moral depletion all involve some kind of moral adversity, Rushton said. And moral resilience—the ability to preserve or restore integrity in response to moral adversity—is a protective resource that could ease professionals' suffering and perhaps forestall serious burnout, PTSD, or decisions to leave the field.

Quantifiable measures such as the Moral Distress Scale-Revised3 have documented high levels of moral distress in nurses and other professionals on a regular basis—but they don't capture the full range of distress experienced in the pandemic and the resulting moral injuries potentially suffered by clinicians. "When we pause, we begin to recognize what has happened," Rushton said of such injuries. "People take a breath and think, 'Oh, my God, what have I participated in? How will I make sense of this?' There's a kind of unraveling of our moral integrity: 'Who am I now?' We feel guilt and shame and regret, even though we could not have met those needs," she said. For others, there is guilt because they didn't face the throes of the COVID surges or were not at the front lines of the pandemic when colleagues were.

"This is a chronic crisis. It's different than a natural disaster, which typically is time limited," Rushton said. "Initially it was all hands on deck. Now we're trying to recalibrate."

'Skeletons of Guilt and Regret'

In a recent perspective piece in the New England Journal of Medicine, Richard Leiter, MD, palliative care physician at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston, described how he led a palliative care team embedded in the ICU from March to June of last year, describing the many difficult decisions made when clinicians everywhere still were learning about COVID-19.4 After feeling he had reached the other side, as the surge abated and more information became available, he described being wholly unprepared for what he felt next: a growing sense of anger, resentment, arousal, pain, isolation, nightmares—"skeletons of guilt and regret," he wrote for the decisions that may not have been "right" and the ways he was unable to honor his palliative care training.

Simon Tavabie, MRCP, a hospice and palliative care doctor working at a major hospital in London, UK, said his colleagues worry about many of the same issues as their American counterparts, including whether there will be enough ICU beds and staffing for the surges, as well as practical things like access to medications like morphine for managing breathlessness. Tavabie is familiar with comparisons of COVID to wartime. "There are a lot of similarities, but doctors and nurses are not soldiers. We're not trained for combat," he said.

"When seeing numbers of patients dying outside of your comfort zone, some people just put on their helmets and march back to the trenches, while others have to struggle to go back to work. They come home after a long day, with no way to unload their feelings, knowing that the next morning they'll just have to do it again," Tavabie said.

One of the changes in his palliative care work was how much more time he has spent supporting other professionals in the hospital during the pandemic. "That's something we are fairly good at. The way we approach each other is similar to how we approach our patients," he said. For himself, Tavabie says there were a few occasions where he felt at the breaking point. "It wasn't around a particular case so much as ongoing pressure, the weight of cases—and fear of what was coming next."

Perceived Self Efficacy

However, "it's important to emphasize that the difficult clinical situations seen in palliative care are not the inherent cause of moral distress," said Billy Rosa, PhD MBE ACHPN FAANP FAAN, chief research fellow in the department of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York City and a palliative care nurse practitioner. "We routinely see pain, suffering, and very complicated situations. We bear witness. But that suffering is now arising in situations that are at odds with our individual moral compasses. We're not able to do what feels right and we don't have the resources we need. We feel that what we're doing isn't enough," Rosa said.

"We came into this field to help meet the goals of palliative care." That includes alleviating suffering; establishing relationships with patients; and understanding their needs, preferences, and values, he said. "The pandemic has maxed out the resources we need to uphold our standards, and that's where moral distress occurs."

It may have been that the visitation restrictions were a good choice to prevent further spread of the virus—at least based on the information available at the time. But that doesn't necessarily help frontline providers, he noted. "I may theoretically be able to stand back and say: 'I understand why.' But that has little to do with the actual experience of the clinician who's unable to respond to the patient's needs in the moment."

Rosa is studying the experiences of interdisciplinary palliative care providers who addressed acute care oncology patients' needs during the initial surge in New York, delivering care using telehealth platforms. His in-depth, qualitative interviews with these providers weren't about moral distress specifically but explored his sources' sense of moral and self-efficacy. "My initial results showed that if providers believed themselves to be ineffective in their work, it was reflected in their distress," he said.

One clinician told Rosa about being on the phone from her home with the daughter of a patient dying in the hospital from COVID. "The daughter is alone with her mother and doesn't know what she's looking at. She says, 'How am I going to know when my mother is dead? She looks very still,'" he said. "My colleague realizes that the patient has just died, and she has to convey that information over the phone." She then had to hang up and was at home, alone, with no way to leave work at work, Rosa continued. "She's in deep grief and she's all alone. There's your moral suffering."

Digging Deeper

Elizabeth Burpee, MD, a frontline physician and researcher with Four Seasons and a hospice and palliative care provider based in Flat Rock, NC, leads a video conferencing education and mentoring program modeled on the University of New Mexico's Project ECHO offering resilience-promoting interventions via a Zoom platform with palliative care clinicians, both in North Carolina and nationally.

"There has been so much said about burnout in recent years. We know we're losing people in all the medical professions. But we have learned that burnout is too broad of a term. We need to dig deeper into causes," she said, which may include the ways moral distress may impact overall clinician distress and burnout. Burpee's work aims to bring the subject of resilience in the face of COVID to the conversation to reduce burnout.

Another concrete service is live debriefing for participants, which she describes as a facilitated session for people who have something in common, "a place to give voice to the difficult work they do and share that with others," she said.

Some commentators recently have questioned the growing emphasis on resilience for healthcare workers, saying it suggests to the professional: you fix it. "The system we have says it's up to you to be okay. We've seen that, and we know it doesn't work," Burpee said. "We know doctors and nurses are burning out, and a certain percentage of them leave the field. We can say the system is not working, and we can acknowledge that burnout impacts patient care."

What's needed, she said, are individual solutions, team solutions, and large-scale institutional changes. "We know we'll have another pandemic—or something else comparable. This is the 40th anniversary of the AIDS epidemic, and we know some people never recovered from that."

Although these focus on burnout, such solutions also are needed for moral distress, Rushton said: "We have to do both—help individual clinicians to harness their inner resources to meet these challenges without degrading their health or integrity and change the system." She calls resilience work a life preserver and a pathway for professionals to reorient themselves and pay attention to what's happening to them to reach a sense of wholeness in their work.

How to Encourage Resilience

Johns Hopkins Hospital provides moral resilience rounds, creating spaces for professionals to talk about what the ethical challenges and moral residue they are carrying in reflective dialogue sessions, Rushton said. "Organizations need to invest in these things—along with a robust ethics infrastructure to identify and address ethical concerns."

Other approaches tried in various settings include building a daily mental practice, such as with mindfulness meditation; finding a "buddy"—someone to lean on and share advice, support, and empathy with; learning to recognize signals of distress and to self-regulate; and having ready access to dedicated counselors.

"Let's acknowledge that we are still in a crisis—still in the pandemic," Rosa said. "Our teams had weekly debriefings and invited open discourse. But much of this has stopped. Why? We're still in crisis. People are still under pressure in their working and personal lives," he observed. "Let's grieve together. Let's talk about what happened and what is happening, and then move on to how we can strengthen the well-being of our workforce."

Rushton encourages Academy members to acknowledge out loud that the suffering of moral distress is real. "[These clinicians] are incredibly resilient people; otherwise they wouldn't be on the front line of the pandemic. But the situations and demands that were placed on them have exceeded their resources. That's not their fault," she said. "This is the time for us to heal and stand together in solidarity, thinking about the emotional and physical costs of the pandemic and becoming involved in creating solutions so we're not in this situation again. This is not one and done. The injury that has occurred with COVID will have long-lasting consequences. We need to commit resources to help our frontline workforce, which is so exhausted. We have to learn something from this pandemic and invest in new models of care—including how to care for those who care for others."

According to Burpee, ultimately, the larger healthcare system will need to take a close look at some longstanding issues, which came to a head in the pandemic. "Healthcare for profit, just in itself, leaves people in moral distress," she said. "When patients are treated differently because of their poverty or lack of insurance, when homeless patients are discharged to the bus stop, that is not amenable to supporting providers in exploring their moral distress.

"One thing that helps me get through distressing events is to try to remember why I came into this field in the first place—remembering my sense of purpose," she said. "If my job is not serving that purpose, maybe I need to tweak the job or go elsewhere. For me, working on issues of equity, diversity, and inclusiveness—training other providers how to better serve the underserved—and how to change our healthcare system, that's helping me to see my place."

Larry Beresford is a medical journalist in Oakland, CA, with a strong interest in hospice and palliative care.

Resources

  • Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics, with COVID-related ethics resources for frontline clinicians: https://bioethics.jhu.edu/research-and-outreach/covid-19-bioethics-expert-insights/resources-for-addressing-key-ethical-areas/resources-for-frontline-clinicians/
  • ELNEC (End-of-Life Nursing Education Consortium) resource page on its website dedicated to self-care, moral distress, and resilience: https://www.aacnnursing.org/ELNEC/COVID-19
  • Moral Injury of Healthcare, a non-profit with COVID resources and a white paper on healing/resolution of moral injury: www.fixmoralinjury.org
  • Psychological personal protective equipment for promoting mental health and wellbeing, with concrete recommendations, from the Institute for Healthcare Improvement: http://www.ihi.org/resources/Pages/Tools/psychological-PPE-promote-health-care-workforce-mental-health-and-well-being.aspx
  • The Moral Distress Education Project of the University of Kentucky's Program for Bioethics: https://moraldistressproject.med.uky.edu/
  • Trauma Stewardship Institute, with keynote talks, workshops, and consultations: https://traumastewardship.com/
  • Frontline Nurses Wiki Wisdom Forum for posting responses to questions among peers: https://nurses.wikiwisdomforum.com/
  • National Academy of Medicine's Action Collaborative on Clinician Well-Being and Resilience: https://nam.edu/action-collaborative-on-clinician-well-being-and-resilience-network-organizations/
  • American Nurses Association wellbeing initiative: https://www.nursingworld.org/practice-policy/work-environment/health-safety/disaster-preparedness/coronavirus/what-you-need-to-know/the-well-being-initiative/

References

  1. Jameton A. Nursing Practice: The Ethical Issues. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall; 1984.
  2. Rushton C, ed. Moral Resilience: Transforming Moral Suffering in Healthcare. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2018.
  3. Hamric AB, et al. Development and testing of an instrument to measure moral distress in healthcare professionals. AJOB Prim Res. 2012;3(2):1–9.
  4. Leiter RE. Reentry. N Engl J Med. 2020;384:e141.

Read the next article or go to the table of contents.

Essential Practices in Hospice and Palliative Medicine

This comprehensive self-study provides a critical foundation for those who want to incorporate principles of hospice and palliative medicine into their daily lives.

Learn More

Quick Links

  • Job Mart
  • JPSM
  • CME/CE Certificates
  • Purchased Activities
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

For Exhibitors and Advertisers

  • Commercial Support
  • Exhibiting
  • Advertising
  • Mailing Labels

For Students and Residents

  • Membership
  • Careers
  • Fellowships
  • Publications
Facebook Twitter Linked In Visit our patient website: PalliativeDoctors.org

AAHPM Logo

8735 West Higgins Road, Suite 300 Chicago, IL 60631

Phone 847-375-4712 Fax 847-375-6475 E-mail info@aahpm.org

Copyright © American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine