Skip to main content
AAHPM Logo
Login
  • Join/Renew
  • Donate
  • Blog
  • Contact
Menu Search Account
  • Membership
    • Join/Renew
      • Member Benefits
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
      • DEI Resources
    • Member Center
    • Getting Involved
    • Communities
      • SIG Instructions
      • Join a SIG
      • Member Councils
    • Mentoring
    • FAAHPM
      • Current Fellows
  • Education & Practice
    • Writing Instructional Objectives
    • Meetings
      • Leadership Forum: Ascend
      • Annual Assembly
        • Back to Meetings
        • Assembly Home
        • About the Assembly
          • Why Attend
        • Registration
        • Special Events
        • Educational Sessions
          • Keynotes
          • Wednesday
          • Thursday
          • Friday
          • Saturday
        • Plan Your Experience
        • CE and MOC
        • Summer Call for Abstracts
        • Fall Call for Abstracts
        • Assembly FAQs
        • Business Meeting
        • Health and Safety
        • Exhibits & Advertising
      • State of the Science
      • State of the Science
        • Back to Meetings
        • State of the Science Home
        • Plan Your Experience
        • Schedule and Pricing
        • SOTS FAQ
        • Virtual State of the Science
      • Intensive Review Course
        • Back to Meetings
        • Home
        • Schedule
        • Plan Your Trip
      • Advanced Course in Pain
        • Back to Meetings
        • Home
        • Plan Your Trip
      • Intensive Board Review Course 2018 Recordings
      • IBRC18 - Additional Management Strategies for Cancer Related Symptoms
      • IBRC18 - Approaches to Care, including Hospice/Medicare
      • IBRC18 - Assessment and Care of the Dying Patient
      • IBRC18 - Communication and Teamwork
      • IBRC18 - Depression/Anxiety & Other Mood Disorders
      • IBRC18 - Ethical and Legal Decision Making
      • IBRC18 - Grief and Bereavement and Spiritual Care
      • IBRC18 - High Yield Pediatrics for the Boards
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – GI
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – Respiratory
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management: Pot-Pourri
      • IBRC18 - Pain Management Overview
      • IBRC18 - Palliative Sedation/Physician-Assisted Dying/Discontinuation of Technological Support
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (1)
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (2)
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (3)
      • IBRC18 - Prognostication
      • IBRC18 - Special Topics in Pain Management
      • IBRC18 - Symptom Potpourri
      • IBRC18 - Taking the Test Like a Pro
      • IBRC18 - Urgent Medical Conditions
    • Publications
      • JPSM
        • Members JPSM
      • PC-FACS
        • Members - PC-FACS
      • Quarterly
        • Members Quarterly Full Access
        • Spring 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 18 Diversity & Inclusion
        • Spring 18 Feature
        • Spring 18 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 18 Presidents Message
        • Spring 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 18 AAHPM News
        • Spring 18 Art of Caring
        • Summer 18 AAHPM News
        • Summer 18 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 18 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 18 Art of Caring
        • Summer 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 18 Ethics
        • Summer 18 Feature
        • Summer 18 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 18 President's Message
        • Summer 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 18 AAHPM News
        • Fall 18 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 18 Art of Caring
        • Fall 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 18 Diversity & Inclusion
        • Fall 18 Feature
        • Fall 18 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 18 President's Message
        • Fall 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 18 AAHPM News
        • Winter 18 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 18 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 18 Art of Caring
        • Winter 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 18 Ethics
        • Winter 18 Feature
        • Winter 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 18 President's Message
        • Winter 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 18 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 19 Editors Message
        • Spring 19 Meet the President
        • Spring 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 19 Art of Caring
        • Spring 19 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 19 Feature
        • Spring 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 19 Diversity and Inclusion
        • Spring 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 19 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 19 AAHPM News
        • Summer 19 Presidents Message
        • Summer 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 19 Art of Caring
        • Summer 19 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 19 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 19 Feature
        • Summer 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 19 Ethics and the Hidden Curriculum
        • Summer 19 Research or Quality Improvement
        • Summer 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 19 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 19 AAHPM News
        • Fall 19 Presidents Message
        • Fall 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 19 Art of Caring
        • Fall 19 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 19 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 19 Feature
        • Fall 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 19 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 19 Quality Improvement
        • Fall 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 19 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 19 AAHPM News
        • Fall 19 State of the Science
        • Winter 19 Presidents Message
        • Winter 19 Editor's Message
        • Winter 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 19 Art of Caring
        • Winter 19 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 19 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 19 Feature
        • Winter 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 19 State of the Science
        • Winter 19 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 19 AAHPM News
        • Spring 20 Presidents Message
        • Spring 20 Meet the President
        • Spring 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Spring 20 Art of Caring
        • Spring 20 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 20 Feature
        • Spring 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 20 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 20 AAHPM News
        • Summer 20 Presidents Message
        • Summer 20 Meet New AAHPM CEO
        • Summer 20 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 20 State of the Science
        • Summer 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 20 Art of Caring
        • Summer 20 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 20 Feature
        • Summer 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 20 AAHPM News
        • Summer 20 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 20 PCQC Update
        • Fall 20 Presidents Message
        • Fall 20 Art of Caring
        • Fall 20 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 20 Lets Think About it Again
        • Fall 20 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 20 Feature
        • Fall 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 20 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 20 PCQC Update
        • Winter 20 Presidents Message
        • Winter 20 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 20 Lets Think About it Again
        • Winter 20 Art of Caring
        • Winter 20 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 20 Feature
        • Winter 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Winter 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 20 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 20 PCQC Update
        • Winter 20 AAHPM News
        • Spring 21 A Message from the CEO
        • Spring 21 Meet the President
        • Spring 21 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 21 Art of Caring
        • Spring 21 Interview with AAFP President
        • Spring 21 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 21 Feature
        • Spring 21 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 21 Lets Think About it Again
        • Spring 21 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Spring 21 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 21 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 21 PCQC Update
        • Spring 21 AAHPM News
        • Summer 21 A Message from the President
        • Summer 21 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 21 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 21 Art of Caring
        • Summer 21 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 21 Feature
        • Summer 21 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 21 Lets Think About it Again
        • Summer 21 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 21 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 21 PCQC Update
        • Summer 21 AAHPM News
        • Fall 21 A Message from the President
        • Fall 21 State of Science
        • Fall 21 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 21 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 21 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 21 Feature
        • Fall 21 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 21 Lets Think About it Again
        • Fall 21 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 21 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 21 Art of Caring
        • Fall 21 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 21 PCQC Update
        • Winter 21 A Message from the President
        • Winter 21 The Bridge Builder
        • Winter 21 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 21 Art of Caring
        • Winter 21 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 21 Feature
        • Winter 21 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 21 Lets Think About it Again
        • Winter 21 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 21 Partner Updates
        • Winter 21 AAHPM News
        • Spring 22 Meet the President
        • Spring 22 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 22 Art of Caring
        • Spring 22 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 22 Feature
        • Spring 22 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 22 Lets Think About It Again
        • Spring 22 DEI LAB
        • Spring 22 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 22 AAHPM Partner Update
        • Spring 22 AAHPM News
        • AAHPM Quarterly: Spring 2022 (Full Issue)
        • Summer 22 A Message from the President
        • Summer 22 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 22 Art of Caring
        • Summer 22 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 22 Feature
        • Summer 22 DEI LAB
        • Summer 22 Quarterly Progress Report
        • AAHPM Quarterly: Summer 2022 (Full Issue)
      • SmartBriefs
    • AAHPM Learn
      • Interactive Activities
    • Self-Study
      • Board Prep Materials
      • Essentials
      • Primer
      • HPM PASS
      • HPM FAST
        • HPM FAST CME
      • Hospice Products
        • HMD Manual
        • HMD PREP
      • Opioid REMS
      • hpmpasscme
      • Opioid Resources
    • Fellowships
      • Competencies
        • Pediatric Competencies
      • Accreditation
      • NRMP Match
      • Grants
        • Ho/Chiang Foundation
      • Hospice Program Toolkit
      • CBME Recordings
    • CME
    • Quality
      • Measuring What Matters
      • Quality Reporting
      • Quality Resources
      • Quality Registries
      • Quality Improvement Education
    • Research
      • Research Funding
      • Successful Research Grants
    • COVID-19 Resources
    • COVID hotel
  • Advocacy
    • Stay Informed
    • Take Action
    • Key Issues
      • Opioids
      • Workforce
  • Career Development
    • Jobs
      • Virtual Career Fair
    • Clinical Training
      • Additional Training
    • Leadership Development
      • AAHPM Ascend
        • Leadership Forum Faculty and Facilitators
        • Ascend Schedule
        • Ascend Facilitators
    • Certification
      • Allopathic
      • Hospice
        • HMDCB Research
      • Osteopathic
    • Continuing HPM Certification
    • Workforce Statistics
    • Scholarships
      • Access Fund
      • Leadership Scholars
      • International Physicians
      • Pediatric Scholarship
      • Research Scholars
      • Next Gen Scholars
    • Resilience and Well-being
  • About
    • History
    • Position Statements
      • Access to Palliative Care and Hospice Position Statement
      • Artificial Nutrition Position Statement
      • Research Ethics Position Statement
      • Palliative Sedation Position Statement
      • Physician-Assisted Dying Position Statement
      • Withholding Position Statement
      • Physician Assisted Dying Position Statement Review
      • Physician-Assisted Dying
    • Talking About HPM
      • Advance Directives-Talking HPM
      • Choosing a Hospice Program-Talking HPM
      • Defining HPM-Talking HPM
      • Explaining PAD-Talking HPM
      • Costs-Talking HPM
      • Withdrawing LST-Talking HPM
      • Choosing Wisely
      • Members Talking About HPM
    • Governance
      • Board of Directors
        • Board Only
        • Past Presidents
      • Committees
      • Staff
        • Staff
      • Call for Nominations
      • Revised Bylaws
    • Giving Center
      • Reasons to Give
      • AAHPM Giving Circle
      • Year End Donations
      • Giving Tuesday Donations
      • Bogetz Educational Fund
      • Donation Form
      • Donation FAQ
    • Awards
      • Visionaries in HPM
      • Emerging Leaders
    • Social Media
  • AAHPM Learn
    • Browse All
    • Books
    • Core Content
    • Self-Study
    • Essentials
  • Legislative Action Center
  • My Account
  • Username & Password
  • Manage Credit Cards
  • Demographics
  • My Classroom
  • Quarterly Newsletter
  • Pay Open Balances
  • Purchase History
  • Membership Details
  • My Communities
  • My Volunteer History
  • Uploaded Documents
  • Writing Instructional Objectives
  • Meetings
    • Leadership Forum: Ascend
    • Annual Assembly
    • State of the Science
    • State of the Science
    • Intensive Review Course
    • Advanced Course in Pain
    • Intensive Board Review Course 2018 Recordings
    • IBRC18 - Additional Management Strategies for Cancer Related Symptoms
    • IBRC18 - Approaches to Care, including Hospice/Medicare
    • IBRC18 - Assessment and Care of the Dying Patient
    • IBRC18 - Communication and Teamwork
    • IBRC18 - Depression/Anxiety & Other Mood Disorders
    • IBRC18 - Ethical and Legal Decision Making
    • IBRC18 - Grief and Bereavement and Spiritual Care
    • IBRC18 - High Yield Pediatrics for the Boards
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – GI
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – Respiratory
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management: Pot-Pourri
    • IBRC18 - Pain Management Overview
    • IBRC18 - Palliative Sedation/Physician-Assisted Dying/Discontinuation of Technological Support
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (1)
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (2)
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (3)
    • IBRC18 - Prognostication
    • IBRC18 - Special Topics in Pain Management
    • IBRC18 - Symptom Potpourri
    • IBRC18 - Taking the Test Like a Pro
    • IBRC18 - Urgent Medical Conditions
  • Publications
    • JPSM
    • PC-FACS
    • Quarterly
    • SmartBriefs
  • AAHPM Learn
    • Interactive Activities
  • Self-Study
    • Board Prep Materials
    • Essentials
    • Primer
    • HPM PASS
    • HPM FAST
    • Hospice Products
    • Opioid REMS
    • hpmpasscme
    • Opioid Resources
  • Fellowships
    • Competencies
    • Accreditation
    • NRMP Match
    • Grants
    • Hospice Program Toolkit
    • CBME Recordings
  • CME
  • Quality
    • Measuring What Matters
    • Quality Reporting
    • Quality Resources
    • Quality Registries
    • Quality Improvement Education
  • Research
    • Research Funding
    • Successful Research Grants
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • COVID hotel

Feature

feature

How Do We Identify Who Needs Palliative Care Most?

By Larry Beresford

Anyone with a serious illness can benefit from palliative care interventions, according to palliative care advocates. But because palliative care resources are finite, the question becomes, who should receive those limited services? What do we really know about the need for palliative care across medical conditions, across groups, and across populations—or, for that matter, which patients could benefit the most from this service? Can we devise more nuanced models, definitions, and criteria for deciding whom our services optimally should try to reach?

If we could define serious illness in ways that ensure palliative care support for those who need it when they need it most, that might help us identify which patients to screen for palliative needs and how to triage for specialty-level palliative care. As our healthcare system rapidly evolves toward new value-based and population health models, how we identify this population has significant implications for the present and future delivery of palliative care. We know that professional staff and other resources in palliative care are finite, and we also know there are misconceptions about palliative care and when it should be used—despite best efforts by advocates to address those misconceptions.

There is no single best way for identifying those who might most benefit from palliative care in all circumstances, but leaders in the field and within AAHPM are engaging with the challenge on a number of fronts with the aim of defining better ways to target, deploy, and utilize this finite palliative care workforce for maximum benefit to patients and families when they need it most.

AAHPM has advocated for advancing basic or primary palliative care, a model of training and support for frontline providers like primary care physicians and nurse practitioners to enable them to address such palliative needs for their patients through tactics like effective pain management and facilitation of conversations about the patients' goals of care. In this model, specialist interprofessional palliative care teams, with their advanced skills, would be reserved for more difficult and complex cases.

But the challenge remains: how do we identify those who could benefit the most and then reduce the barriers that stand in the way of accessing this service? "How do we find the patients who should get palliative care?" asked Katherine Ast, MSW LCSW, AAHPM's director of quality and research. "This question comes up at the patient care level, but also at the level of health systems, health plans, and other groups responsible for managing the health of defined populations."

What Do We Mean by Serious Illness?

Serious illness has been defined as "a health condition that carries a high risk of mortality and either negatively impacts a person's daily function or quality of life or excessively strains their caregivers."1 That is a definition rooted in the patient's experience, but is there a method to identify patients with serious illness using algorithms programmed into the electronic health record (EHR) and other data sources?

"If you could prospectively identify a seriously ill patient population, how would you use that information to improve care at a population level? Who would you connect with basic or with specialized palliative care? What we are talking about, ultimately, are measures of care quality," Ast said. So part of the challenge is to advance care quality by advancing the science of quality measurement in palliative medicine.

AAHPM has a 3-year cooperative agreement (#1V1CMS331639) from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to develop quality measures for community-based palliative care that are intended for use in the government's value-based quality initiatives. It also has fostered the creation of the Palliative Care Quality Collaborative with support from the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation to develop a unified registry to capture both program- and patient-level quality data for patients with serious illness, including those receiving palliative care, and has partnered with the Hospice and Palliative Nurses Association on "Measuring What Matters," an initiative that highlights 10 measures that matter to our field. (See aahpm.org/quality/measuring-what-matters for more information.)

AAHPM also is collaborating with OptumLabs® and AMGA on an AARP-funded serious illness denominator project utilizing the OptumLabs Data Warehouse to examine how big healthcare databases might be used to help identify the patients who need palliative care. This project aims to use data from EHRs and healthcare claims to find populations of patients who are seriously ill but have not been identified as such so they can be offered palliative care services and enable clinicians to capture their data in palliative care quality measurement.

That has involved convening subject matter experts, engaging stakeholders, and then testing and refining the denominator of appropriate patients. "We have explored the use of diagnostic codes, utilization codes, and durable medical equipment orders to get at the type and severity of illness. We have looked to define and identify patients with multiple chronic conditions in these databases," Ast said. "We'd like to leverage the information that exists in the EHR, such as patient falls, caregiver stress, or other nuggets that might be found in provider notes, by using natural language processing."

This technology is still a ways off, but researchers like Charlotta Lindvall, MD PhD, a palliative care physician at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston, MA, already are exploring machine learning to identify triggers for a palliative care consultation. (See the fall 2019 issue of AAHPM Quarterly for more information.)

As the researchers dig deeper into the serious illness denominator, it's clear that not all of the needed data can be found in existing databases of health plans and health systems. And that's just one piece of the puzzle, Ast said. "Right now, our work is purely a research initiative. We're not ready yet to identify actual triggers for palliative care or to identify the patients who should be targeted. We still don't have perfect equations for capturing patients who would benefit most and respond the best. Multiple denominators will be needed for various purposes and unique population groups. But AAHPM keeps trying to push the envelope."

The Importance of Function

Another way to frame these issues is around maximizing efficient use of resources, said Amy Kelley, MD, associate professor of geriatrics and palliative medicine at Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York City. "As a field, we have the broadest concern that people with serious illness deserve high-quality palliative care." A condition could have a high mortality risk, but it also may impact activities of daily living and quality of life, she said. "It's not enough to know the diagnosis. When you add information about functional limitations, or the fact that the patient's husband has dementia, you have a better basis to make these determinations. That's the reality of our patients—and how we should be trying to identify who should be on the list to receive a palliative care referral."

Kelley said there is not a single denominator for palliative care need, either primary or secondary. "I believe the healthcare system needs to be measuring functional status in some systematic fashion and systematically recording it. Functional status is a critical indicator of well-being. It gets at disease severity, but also at the impact of the disease on the person's life. I'm working with the Center to Advance Palliative Care on a collaborative initiative for the National Quality Forum advocating for a national strategy to make palliative care more accessible to consumers. One of our goals is to get functional status routinely measured. At a conceptual level, function provides another fundamental layer to understanding serious illness."

Christine Ritchie, MD MSPH FACP FAAHPM, director of research in the division of palliative care and geriatric medicine at Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, agrees that functional limitation is an important part of the conversation because it has been implicated in both prognosis and outcomes—and there are validated measures for it. "Our work is [focused on] showing how functional status interacts with underlying chronic illness. It is a critical indicator of well-being and of prognosis," she said. "But the EHR doesn't tell us all the information we need in a consistent, constructive form. How will you decide who needs palliative care if you don't have clear definitions? How are you going to know if high-quality care was given to patients?" According to Ritchie, these issues are increasing in importance for policy makers and for payers.

Who Has Access to Palliative Care?

Another crucial part of this conversation for leaders in the field involves barriers to palliative care use. These include racial/cultural differences and the barriers to access that disproportionally impact some patient groups. Misunderstandings and misinformation about palliative care, some of which may be exacerbated by these cultural differences, include a belief that palliative care is intended for the end of life only. Other barriers include lack of insurance coverage; geographical barriers, particularly between rural versus urban settings or by region; and financial disparities and other social determinants of health.

"As a field, we have moved from emphasizing equality of access to equity, with a focus on responding to actual patient needs," said Jane Loitman, MD MBA MS FAAHPM, a private practice palliative care physician in St. Louis, MO. Equity means those who need the service most are most likely to receive it—not that everyone has equal access to it. "We just have to keep doing what we can do and recognize that not everyone needs palliative care. We keep trying to define our niche, and for most of us, like it or not, that niche has turned out to be potentially life-limiting illnesses," Loitman said.

"Who needs palliative care today and isn't getting it?" asked Joe Rotella, MD MBA HMDC FAAHPM, AAHPM's chief medical officer. "Where are the gaps? Can you identify a population with serious illness and [that is] likely to have palliative needs and make that your denominator for quality measures, or use it to power a predictive modeling algorithm? How can we use tools at the system level to make sure the best care is delivered at a personal level?"

To answer these questions, Rotella said, the field needs to ask what we mean by benefitting the most from palliative care. "Is it defined by the individual? Relative to what goal? Is it a better patient experience or better clinical outcomes based on measures of quality of life? Or is the outcome defined by payers and their quest for value—trying to make sure that they are not paying for unnecessary and unwanted medical interventions across covered populations?" he asked. The criteria thus may differ depending on whether they reflect the perspective of patients, populations, or payers.

Rotella urges caution in focusing on limits in palliative care capacity. "As a field, palliative care is still in the mode of raising awareness about the value of our services. As demand for palliative care grows, we could develop better training, service, and payment models to meet the needs and trust that the capacity could follow," he explained.

"If we could do a better job of identifying who benefits most from palliative care and what that actual benefit is, would it be possible to attract more investment in palliative care infrastructure?" Rotella asked. "The real excitement around palliative care denominator research is what it offers for value-based coverage. We would like to find these people even before their first disastrous hospitalization."

Other Perspectives on Palliative Care Need

AAHPM members and other leaders in the field offer additional perspectives on how to bring clarity to these questions. Somewhere in the interaction of identified need, access, barriers to service, and enhanced understanding of what palliative care can offer patients lie some important insights that could help advance the field.

Steven Baumrucker, MD FAAFP FAAHPM, system medical director for palliative medicine in the Ballad Health System of Upper East Tennessee, points out that CMS's Oncology Care Model (OCM), a pilot program designed to improve the quality of cancer care at the same or lower cost through a voluntary managed oncology approach, also mandates that every patient who starts palliative chemotherapy at participating oncology practices must be provided access to palliative care services.

OCM is a 5-year model from 2016 to 2021 to test innovative payment strategies, including real-time monthly payment models; advanced service models; and retrospective, performance-based payment based on quality and shared savings. "Our palliative care service grew from a half-day to 4 days per week after the system decided to comply with this rule through consultation on day one of chemotherapy," Baumrucker said. The oncologist can simply click a button on the EHR to trigger the referral.

Marie Bakitas, DNSc CRNP, professor of nursing at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, has been involved in several research initiatives offering further insights on how to understand these questions. "We have learned a lot over the years about who does and does not need palliative care," she said.

For example, Project ENABLE (Educate, Nurture, Advise, Before Life's End) tried to include every patient who was newly diagnosed with advanced cancer and found that those with high depression scores responded better—with greater improvements in quality of life and on survival outcomes—than those who did not.

Subsequent research by Bakitas studied palliative care for patients with cardiovascular disease. "We looked at 415 patients with heart disease, half of them African American. We found that, unlike other studies, we did not achieve dramatic improvements in their quality of life using a heart failure–specific measure," she said. Perhaps the study population was already fully optimized from a cardiac perspective and not sick enough to realize measurable improvements on that scale. Or, according to Bakitas, perhaps there are other, unmeasured aspects of care where palliative care makes a bigger difference.

"One possible conclusion is that rather than offering palliative care services, for example, to every newly diagnosed patient with advanced cancer, perhaps we should instead target those who we believe would benefit the most, such as those with depression or those who have some threshold of symptoms," she observed.

"We were all encouraged with results showing that early palliative care benefits patients, such as ENABLE and Dr. Jennifer Temel's landmark study.2 But at the end of the day, if we say, as the American Society of Clinical Oncology has proposed, that everyone with metastatic disease and symptom burden should get palliative care, are we recommending something that we'll never be able to achieve, especially in low resource areas and smaller hospitals?" she asked.

"We don't have the best instruments for measuring what palliative care does to benefit people and for identifying those who need specialized palliative support before it becomes obvious. Wouldn't it be better to identify some basic, evidence-based triggers to target our efforts?"

Regardless of how this change manifests, however, it's clear that to ensure palliative services are reaching the patients who can benefit from them most, more work is needed to answer these—and many more—questions.

References

  1. National Consensus Project for Quality Palliative Care. Clinical Practice Guidelines for Quality Palliative Care. 4th ed. Richmond, VA: National Coalition for Hospice and Palliative Care; 2018. www.nationalcoalitionhpc.org/ncp/.
  2. Temel JS, Greer JA, Muzikansky MA, et al. Early palliative care for patients with metastatic non–small-cell lung cancer. New Engl J Med. 2010;363:733–742.

Larry Beresford is an Oakland, CA–based freelance medical journalist specializing in hospice and palliative care. Contact him at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or visit his website at larryberesford.com.


Read the next article or go to the table of contents.

Essential Practices in Hospice and Palliative Medicine

This comprehensive self-study provides a critical foundation for those who want to incorporate principles of hospice and palliative medicine into their daily lives.

Learn More

Quick Links

  • Job Mart
  • JPSM
  • CME/CE Certificates
  • Purchased Activities
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

For Exhibitors and Advertisers

  • Commercial Support
  • Exhibiting
  • Advertising
  • Mailing Labels

For Students and Residents

  • Membership
  • Careers
  • Fellowships
  • Publications
Facebook Twitter Linked In Visit our patient website: PalliativeDoctors.org

AAHPM Logo

8735 West Higgins Road, Suite 300 Chicago, IL 60631

Phone 847-375-4712 Fax 847-375-6475 E-mail info@aahpm.org

Copyright © American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine