Skip to main content
AAHPM Logo
Login
  • Join/Renew
  • Blog
  • Contact
Menu Search Account
  • Membership
    • Join/Renew
      • Member Benefits
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
    • Member Center
    • Getting Involved
    • Communities
      • SIG Instructions
      • Join a SIG
      • Member Councils
    • Mentoring
    • FAAHPM
      • Current Fellows
  • Education & Practice
    • Writing Instructional Objectives
    • Meetings
      • Annual Assembly
        • Registration
        • Back to Meetings
        • Assembly Home
        • About the Assembly
          • Why Attend
        • Educational Sessions
          • Plenaries
        • Plan Your Experience
        • CE and MOC
        • Exhibits & Advertising
        • Call for Case and Scholar Posters
        • Assembly FAQs
        • Call for Papers and Posters
          • Topics for Assembly
        • Business Meeting
      • Leadership Forum: Ascend
      • State of the Science
      • State of the Science
        • Back to Meetings
        • Home
      • Board Review Course
        • Back to Meetings
        • Home
        • Schedule
      • Calendar
      • Intensive Board Review Course 2018 Recordings
      • IBRC18 - Additional Management Strategies for Cancer Related Symptoms
      • IBRC18 - Approaches to Care, including Hospice/Medicare
      • IBRC18 - Assessment and Care of the Dying Patient
      • IBRC18 - Communication and Teamwork
      • IBRC18 - Depression/Anxiety & Other Mood Disorders
      • IBRC18 - Ethical and Legal Decision Making
      • IBRC18 - Grief and Bereavement and Spiritual Care
      • IBRC18 - High Yield Pediatrics for the Boards
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – GI
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – Respiratory
      • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management: Pot-Pourri
      • IBRC18 - Pain Management Overview
      • IBRC18 - Palliative Sedation/Physician-Assisted Dying/Discontinuation of Technological Support
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (1)
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (2)
      • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (3)
      • IBRC18 - Prognostication
      • IBRC18 - Special Topics in Pain Management
      • IBRC18 - Symptom Potpourri
      • IBRC18 - Taking the Test Like a Pro
      • IBRC18 - Urgent Medical Conditions
    • Publications
      • JPSM
        • Members JPSM
      • PC-FACS
        • Members - PC-FACS
      • Quarterly
        • Members Quarterly Full Access
          • Summer 14 President's Message
          • Summer 14 Academy News
          • Summer 14 Advocacy Updates
          • summer 14 Art of Caring
          • Summer 14 Clinical Pearls
          • Summer 14 Progress Report
          • summer 14 communities
          • summer 14 Assembly
          • Fall14 Academy News
          • Fall 14 Advocacy Update
          • Fall 14 Annual Assembly
          • Fall 14 Art of Caring
          • Fall 14 Clinical Pearls
          • Fall 14 Feature
          • Fall 14 HMDCB
          • Fall 14 President
          • Fall 14 Progress
          • Winter 14 Clinical Pearls
          • Winter 14 Leaders
          • Winter 14 AAHPM News
          • Winter 14 Advocacy Update
          • Winter 14 Art of Caring
          • Winter 14 Board of Directors
          • Winter 14 Feature
          • Winter 14 HMDCB Exam
          • Winter 14 Paper Sessions
          • Winter 14 President's Message
          • Winter 14 Progress Report
          • Spring 15 President's Message
          • Spring 15 Clinical Pearls
          • Spring 15 Advocacy Update
          • Spring 15 Art of Caring
          • Spring 15 Feature
          • Spring 15 HMDCB Certification
          • Spring 15 Communities Update
          • Spring 15 Shaping the Future
          • Spring 15 AAHPM News
          • Summer 15 AAHPM News
          • Summer 14 Feature
          • Summer 15 AAHPM Summer Institute
          • Summer 15 Advocacy Update
          • Summer 15 Annual Assembly
          • Summer 15 Art of Caring
          • Summer 15 Clinical Pearls
          • Summer 15 Communities Update
          • Summer 15 Feature
          • Summer 15 HMDCB Exam
          • Summer 15 Meet Joe Rotella
          • Summer 15 President's Message
          • Summer 15 Quarterly Progress Report
          • Fall 15 Feature
          • Fall 15 AAHPM News
          • Fall 15 Annual Assembly
          • Fall 15 President's Message
          • Fall 15 Advocacy Update
          • Fall 15 Clinical Pearls
          • Fall 15 Art of Caring
          • Fall 15 Quarterly Progress Report
          • Fall 15 HMDCB Certification
          • Winter 15 AAHPM News
          • Winter 15 Advocacy Update
          • Winter 15 Annual Assembly
          • Winter 15 Art of Caring
          • Winter 15 Clinical Pearls
          • Winter 15 Feature
          • Winter 15 HMDCB Certification
          • Winter 15 President's Message
          • Spring 2016 Feature
          • Spring 2016 President's Message
          • Spring 2016 Clinical Pearls
          • Spring 2016 Art of Caring
          • Spring 2016 Ethics
          • Spring 2016 Communities Update
          • Spring 2016 Quarterly Progress Report
          • Spring 2016 AAHPM News
          • Summer 16 AAHPM News
          • Summer 16 Advocacy Update
          • Summer 16 Art of Caring
          • Summer 16 Assembly Recap
          • Summer 16 Clinical Pearls
          • Summer 16 Communities Update
          • Summer 16 Death Cafe
          • Summer 16 Feature
          • Summer 16 HMDCB Update
          • Summer 16 President's Message
          • Summer 16 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 16 AAHPM News
        • Fall 16 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 16 Art of Caring
        • Fall 16 Assembly Promo
        • Fall 16 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 16 Ethics
        • Fall 16 Feature
        • Fall 16 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 16 President's Message
        • Fall 16 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 16 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 16 AAHPM News
        • Winter 16 Art of Caring
        • Winter 16 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 16 Ethics
        • Winter 16 Feature
        • Winter 16 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 16 President's Message
        • Winter 16 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 16 Assembly Paper Sessions
        • Spring 17 AAHPM News
        • Spring 17 Art of Caring
        • Spring 17 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 17 Feature
        • Spring 17 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 17 President's Message
        • Spring 17 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 17 Stay Certified
        • Summer 17 AAHPM News
        • Summer 17 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 17 Art of Caring
        • Summer 17 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 17 Ethics
        • Summer 17 Feature
        • Summer 17 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 17 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 17 President's Message
        • Summer 17 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 17 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 17 President's Message
        • Fall 17 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 17 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 17 Feature
        • Fall 17 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 17 Art of Caring
        • Fall 17 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 17 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 17 AAHPM News
        • Winter 17 AAHPM News
        • Winter 17 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 17 Art of Caring
        • Winter 17 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 17 Feature
        • Winter 17 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 17 All About Essentials
        • Winter 17 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 17 President's Message
        • Winter 17 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 18 Diversity & Inclusion
        • Spring 18 Feature
        • Spring 18 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 18 Presidents Message
        • Spring 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 18 AAHPM News
        • Spring 18 Art of Caring
        • Summer 18 AAHPM News
        • Summer 18 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 18 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 18 Art of Caring
        • Summer 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 18 Ethics
        • Summer 18 Feature
        • Summer 18 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 18 President's Message
        • Summer 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 18 AAHPM News
        • Fall 18 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 18 Art of Caring
        • Fall 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 18 Diversity & Inclusion
        • Fall 18 Feature
        • Fall 18 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 18 President's Message
        • Fall 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 18 AAHPM News
        • Winter 18 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 18 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 18 Art of Caring
        • Winter 18 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 18 Ethics
        • Winter 18 Feature
        • Winter 18 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 18 President's Message
        • Winter 18 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 18 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 19 Editors Message
        • Spring 19 Meet the President
        • Spring 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 19 Art of Caring
        • Spring 19 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 19 Feature
        • Spring 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 19 Diversity and Inclusion
        • Spring 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 19 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 19 AAHPM News
        • Summer 19 Presidents Message
        • Summer 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 19 Art of Caring
        • Summer 19 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 19 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 19 Feature
        • Summer 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 19 Ethics and the Hidden Curriculum
        • Summer 19 Research or Quality Improvement
        • Summer 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 19 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 19 AAHPM News
        • Fall 19 Presidents Message
        • Fall 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 19 Art of Caring
        • Fall 19 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 19 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 19 Feature
        • Fall 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 19 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 19 Quality Improvement
        • Fall 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 19 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 19 AAHPM News
        • Fall 19 State of the Science
        • Winter 19 Presidents Message
        • Winter 19 Editor's Message
        • Winter 19 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 19 Art of Caring
        • Winter 19 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 19 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 19 Feature
        • Winter 19 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 19 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 19 State of the Science
        • Winter 19 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 19 AAHPM News
        • Spring 20 Presidents Message
        • Spring 20 Meet the President
        • Spring 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Spring 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Spring 20 Art of Caring
        • Spring 20 Advocacy Update
        • Spring 20 Feature
        • Spring 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Spring 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Spring 20 HMDCB Update
        • Spring 20 AAHPM News
        • Summer 20 Presidents Message
        • Summer 20 Meet New AAHPM CEO
        • Summer 20 Annual Assembly
        • Summer 20 State of the Science
        • Summer 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Summer 20 Art of Caring
        • Summer 20 Advocacy Update
        • Summer 20 Feature
        • Summer 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Summer 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Summer 20 AAHPM News
        • Summer 20 HMDCB Update
        • Summer 20 PCQC Update
        • Fall 20 Presidents Message
        • Fall 20 Art of Caring
        • Fall 20 Annual Assembly
        • Fall 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Fall 20 Lets Think About it Again
        • Fall 20 Advocacy Update
        • Fall 20 Feature
        • Fall 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Fall 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Fall 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Fall 20 HMDCB Update
        • Fall 20 PCQC Update
        • Winter 20 Presidents Message
        • Winter 20 Annual Assembly
        • Winter 20 Clinical Pearls
        • Winter 20 Lets Think About it Again
        • Winter 20 Art of Caring
        • Winter 20 Advocacy Update
        • Winter 20 Feature
        • Winter 20 Pathways to Palliative Care
        • Winter 20 Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion
        • Winter 20 Quarterly Progress Report
        • Winter 20 HMDCB Update
        • Winter 20 PCQC Update
        • Winter 20 AAHPM News
      • SmartBriefs
    • Self-Study
      • Board Prep Materials
      • Essentials
      • Primer
      • HPM PASS
      • HPM FAST
        • HPM FAST CME
      • Hospice Products
        • HMD Manual
        • HMD PREP
          • HMD PREP CME
      • Opioid REMS
      • Recordings
      • hpmpasscme
      • HPMQ
      • Opioid Resources
    • Fellowships
      • Competencies
        • Pediatric Competencies
      • Accreditation
      • NRMP Match
      • Grants
        • Ho/Chiang Foundation
      • Hospice Program Toolkit
    • CME
    • Quality
      • Measuring What Matters
      • Quality Reporting
      • Quality Resources
      • Quality Registries
      • Quality Improvement Education
    • Research
      • Research Funding
      • Successful Research Grants
    • COVID-19 Resources
    • COVID hotel
  • Advocacy
    • Stay Informed
    • Take Action
    • Key Issues
      • Opioids
      • Workforce
  • Career Development
    • Jobs
      • Virtual Career Fair
    • Clinical Training
      • Additional Training
    • Leadership Development
      • AAHPM Ascend
        • Leadership Forum Faculty and Facilitators
        • Ascend Schedule
        • Ascend Facilitators
      • AAHPM Elevate
    • Certification
      • Allopathic
      • Hospice
        • HMDCB Research
      • Osteopathic
    • Continuing HPM Certification
    • Workforce Statistics
    • Scholarships
      • Access Fund
      • Leadership Scholars
      • International Physicians
      • Pediatric Scholarship
      • Research Scholars
    • Resilience and Well-being
  • About
    • History
    • Position Statements
      • Access to Palliative Care and Hospice Position Statement
      • Artificial Nutrition Position Statement
      • Research Ethics Position Statement
      • Palliative Sedation Position Statement
      • Physician-Assisted Dying Position Statement
      • Withholding Position Statement
      • Physician Assisted Dying Position Statement Review
      • Physician-Assisted Dying
    • Talking About HPM
      • Advance Directives-Talking HPM
      • Choosing a Hospice Program-Talking HPM
      • Defining HPM-Talking HPM
      • Explaining PAD-Talking HPM
      • Costs-Talking HPM
      • Withdrawing LST-Talking HPM
      • Choosing Wisely
      • Members Talking About HPM
    • Governance
      • Board of Directors
        • Board Only
        • Past Presidents
      • Committees
      • Staff
        • Staff
      • Revised Bylaws
    • Donate
      • AAHPM Giving Circle
    • Awards
      • Visionaries in HPM
      • Emerging Leaders
    • Social Media
  • Store
    • Browse All
    • Books
    • E-Learning
    • Recordings
    • Essentials
  • My Account
  • Username & Password
  • Manage Credit Cards
  • Demographics
  • My Classroom
  • Quarterly Newsletter
  • Pay Open Balances
  • Purchase History
  • Membership Details
  • My Communities
  • My Volunteer History
  • Uploaded Documents
  • Writing Instructional Objectives
  • Meetings
    • Annual Assembly
    • Leadership Forum: Ascend
    • State of the Science
    • State of the Science
    • Board Review Course
    • Calendar
    • Intensive Board Review Course 2018 Recordings
    • IBRC18 - Additional Management Strategies for Cancer Related Symptoms
    • IBRC18 - Approaches to Care, including Hospice/Medicare
    • IBRC18 - Assessment and Care of the Dying Patient
    • IBRC18 - Communication and Teamwork
    • IBRC18 - Depression/Anxiety & Other Mood Disorders
    • IBRC18 - Ethical and Legal Decision Making
    • IBRC18 - Grief and Bereavement and Spiritual Care
    • IBRC18 - High Yield Pediatrics for the Boards
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – GI
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management – Respiratory
    • IBRC18 - Non-Pain Symptom Management: Pot-Pourri
    • IBRC18 - Pain Management Overview
    • IBRC18 - Palliative Sedation/Physician-Assisted Dying/Discontinuation of Technological Support
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (1)
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (2)
    • IBRC18 - Practice Test Question Review Q&A (3)
    • IBRC18 - Prognostication
    • IBRC18 - Special Topics in Pain Management
    • IBRC18 - Symptom Potpourri
    • IBRC18 - Taking the Test Like a Pro
    • IBRC18 - Urgent Medical Conditions
  • Publications
    • JPSM
    • PC-FACS
    • Quarterly
    • SmartBriefs
  • Self-Study
    • Board Prep Materials
    • Essentials
    • Primer
    • HPM PASS
    • HPM FAST
    • Hospice Products
    • Opioid REMS
    • Recordings
    • hpmpasscme
    • HPMQ
    • Opioid Resources
  • Fellowships
    • Competencies
    • Accreditation
    • NRMP Match
    • Grants
    • Hospice Program Toolkit
  • CME
  • Quality
    • Measuring What Matters
    • Quality Reporting
    • Quality Resources
    • Quality Registries
    • Quality Improvement Education
  • Research
    • Research Funding
    • Successful Research Grants
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • COVID hotel

Feature

Feature

A Complex Landscape of Certification and Credentialing Defines the HPM Workforce

By Larry Beresford

Shortfalls in the subspecialty-trained and -credentialed workforce in hospice and palliative medicine (HPM) in the United States have been well documented1 and have been a major focus for the American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine (AAHPM) for nearly a decade. Progress is being made on a number of fronts, but need continues to outstrip supply. Although the Academy is not responsible for board certification of physicians in HPM, it is actively engaged in providing education and resources, as well as advocating on behalf of its members.

“We just don’t have enough people trained in the subspecialty of HPM or in generalist palliative care skills like pain management or communication with patients and families about treatment decisions,” said Holly Yang, MD MSHPEd HMDC FACP FAAHPM, a palliative care physician in San Diego, CA, and immediate past-chair of AAHPM’s Workforce Advisory Group.

“It’s a critical issue of access for patients and families who have serious illnesses. At the same time, we are gaining ground and have more highly trained people than we’ve ever had,” Yang said. “But state and national advocacy will be critical for us to continue to work on improving access to care from appropriately credentialed professionals for our patients and families who need palliative care and hospice.”

With demand continuing to increase for both hospice and palliative care, the good news is that HPM has become well established as a medical subspecialty and as an essential part of the healthcare continuum. In a sense, the workforce pressures and dilemmas reflect the field’s successes over the past decade in achieving recognition as a legitimate medical subspecialty with a particular body of knowledge. But with that recognition comes limitations imposed by the medical establishment.

The push to achieve recognition as a subspecialty led to a decision in 2006 by the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS) and 10 of its constituent specialty boards to offer HPM subspecialty board certification starting in 2008. The American Osteopathic Association (AOA) and four of its constituent boards instituted similar recognition.

Previously, approximately 5,000 practicing HPM physicians were allowed to sit for the ABMS and AOA board certification exams based on their work experience and prior certification from the former American Board of Hospice and Palliative Medicine without having to complete a fellowship, a process known as “grandfathering.” But starting in 2012, board certification has required completion of a full-time, full-year fellowship in an accredited HPM fellowship program, just as with other recognized medical specialties. Current cumulative totals are 7,618 HPM board certifications from ABMS and AOA—and 7,469 active certifications.

What Are the Workforce ‘Inputs’?

Workforce inputs—the various factors that shape the complex landscape of the HPM workforce—include the number of annual HPM fellowship slots, currently 344 based at 143 accredited programs (including about 25 pediatric HPM slots). Even though the number of fellowship slots has grown year over year, with projected physician shortfalls in the thousands, the field likely could use 500–600 slots per year. But such rapid growth would require greatly expanded funding for training sites. It also is unclear whether there are enough residents interested in filling that many slots given the current “fill rate” for fellowship programs of 88%.

Board certification is the gold standard for physician credentialing, driving the search for alternatives to a full- time, year-long fellowship to qualify. “I think for a long time, people thought that maybe once we got in the door, we could convince the medical establishment that hospice and palliative medicine is unique and might be treated differently,” said Steve Smith, AAHPM executive director and CEO. “But we’ve been told multiple times by ABMS that granting board certification without a traditional fellowship is not going to happen—even though there are creative alternatives that have been proposed and explored.” However, as graduate medical education moves toward competency-based training, there will be new opportunities to propose innovative fellowship models in the future.

Some board-certified physicians in HPM eventually will leave the workforce as the result of retirement or prematurely in response to stress, burnout, lack of job satisfaction, and other factors. Others may be dissuaded from keeping up their board certification status because of the requirements for maintaining their certification in their primary field—particularly if they feel these requirements are not relevant to their current medical practice in HPM.

Mid-career physicians who feel an affinity for this work may find it difficult to take time off for a year-long, full-time fellowship in HPM in order to qualify for subspecialty board certification—even though they may bring experience and personal qualities that the field needs. “Being drawn to this work doesn’t necessarily happen at the beginning of a medical career. Many physicians only develop an interest in palliative or end-of-life care after considerable professional and life experience,” said Dale Lupu, MPH PhD, associate research professor in the Center for Aging, Health, and Humanities at George Washington University. “We need innovative options for physicians who want to enter the subspecialty mid-career.”

Other new models are emerging for those who seek additional expertise in hospice and palliative care but don’t plan to become HPM subspecialists. Two interdisciplinary Master of Science degree programs in palliative care at the University of Colorado and University of Maryland offer online access and flexible schedules for most or all of their curriculum. The Hospice Medical Director Certification Board (HMDCB) is another avenue for recognizing and credentialing a relevant skill set, having credentialed nearly a thousand physicians for demonstrating the skills needed to serve as a medical director in hospice care.

Physicians practicing in hospice aren’t always fellowship trained, so offering this additional HMDC credential has been a very good thing, Yang said. “It’s a certification that recognizes physicians for expertise in hospice care based on their time spent providing hospice care and a knowledge exam. It’s a mark that you have the know-how to care for people who need hospice care, with a specialized body of knowledge. Some of us are certified both ways: HPM and HMDC.”

Efforts to engage, motivate, and train all physicians in primary palliative care also are important to help extend capacity and complement the credentialed subspecialists. “But training in this area is very ad hoc and we don’t have a way currently to give a stamp of approval for skills in primary palliative care or to quantify the extent to which practitioners possess primary palliative care skills,” Lupu said.

The Supply and Demand Model

Yang compared workforce issues in HPM to any economic model of supply and demand. “What is the job market for new fellows? Where are the gaps in supply and demand? And looking at the other side, what do these new people think about their career opportunities? We can say there is not enough workforce—but we’ve never had enough doctors in this field,” she said. “That doesn’t mean we should stop trying to advocate for increasing the workforce, but I’m from the glass-is-filling school. I think our field has become more recognized by mainstream medicine as we’ve expanded our role and moved into newer areas such as community-based palliative care.”

Every year the fellowship numbers go up, Yang said. “But the issue remains: how do we draw more people into the field and enable them to practice to the maximum of their training? We need a workforce of people who truly care about and are committed to this work. How can we be more creative in growing the field?” she asked. Burnout is another huge topic in medicine, Yang said. “How can the Academy help promote resiliency for its members, which could help them stay in their careers longer?” (See AAHPM’s spring 2018 Quarterly newsletter for an exploration of this subject.)

F. Amos Bailey, MD FACP FAAHPM, professor of palliative medicine and founding director of the Master of Science in Palliative Care/Interprofessional Palliative Care Certification at the University of Colorado, was involved in the push to make HPM a subspecialty. “I’ve always been supportive, and I thought becoming a board subspecialty was the right thing to do in order for us to have credibility as a field. It certainly has lent credibility to the university work I do as a tenured full professor. So from an academic standpoint, it was the right thing to do,” he said.

But despite opening some doors, the recognition may have closed others. “When we look at the landscape of our field, I see a lot of people who were grandfathered in that are now at an advancing age. I’m 61, and it’s hard for me to think that the board-certified doctors who are now approaching retirement age will be easily replaced. It’s also clear that we’re never going to make up the gap by fellowships alone,” he said.

“I also see a number of mid-career physicians who work in family practice, internal medicine, or other specialties but have found a vocation for palliative care. I use that word intentionally—it really is a calling and a practice they feel they are supposed to be doing with their lives. Some of them might feel this calling so greatly that they’d quit their jobs to do a full-year, full-time fellowship. Others can’t do a fellowship, and for many doctors there are limits to how much they can achieve with self-education,” he said. “ABMS and ACGME are careful about the quality of training a person needs to complete in order to be eligible for board certification. They don’t want it to be devalued. And that’s our dilemma.”

Online Education Innovations

For Dr. Bailey, the Master in Palliative Care at the University of Colorado offers a partial answer. The interprofessional coursework prepares professionals to work as a palliative care providers in the community. Physicians, nurses, pharmacists, and physician assistants can earn a master’s degree after completing the full program of 12 classes and 36 credit hours over 2 years of training, along with a capstone scholarly project.

“We’ll graduate our first 13 master participants in July, and we have potential to scale up from there. We use the best online pedagogy and offer it asynchronously, but also with three 4-day, long-weekend, on-campus intensives,” Bailey said. The program is set up to mirror the HPM fellowship curriculum as much as possible. “We’re case based and narrative driven. Every week’s coursework starts with a video of a simulated patient/family encounter, with problems to solve that lend themselves to bio-medical, psychosocial, spiritual, and ethical approaches,” he said.

A similar master’s program, offered entirely online at the University of Maryland, started in the spring of 2017 with 130 participants. Courses are team-taught by experts in the field. “I’m a big fan of self-determined learning,” said the program’s director, Mary Lynn McPherson, PharmD. It includes 10 courses and 30 academic credits. Initial sessions present principles and practices of hospice and palliative medicine, and then students can specialize and earn two or more of five specialized graduate certificates. Final courses for the master’s degree highlight research and clinical outcomes and other courses explore advanced illness in special settings and communication skills refinement.

“One thing I hear from our participating physicians is they want to sit for board exams after completing our master’s program,” Bailey said. “I have to tell them that is not feasible. Physicians who complete our program will have the skills to start hospice and palliative programs and to perform palliative consultations. But it will be up to their institutions whether or not to accept this credential for those roles.”

Maintenance of Certification Generates Controversy

One of the biggest flashpoints in physician credentialing today is maintenance of certification (MOC), which is defined by ABMS as “a system of ongoing professional development and practice assessment and improvement” for the continuous development of board-certified physicians’ skill sets. MOC is complicated, Lupu said, and that’s part of what people don’t like about it. Since 2015, ABMS has been working on addressing physicians’ dissatisfaction with MOC, trying to place greater emphasis on practical applications such as patient safety and working on teams.

Different specialty boards have taken different approaches to MOC for HPM. Half require continuing the doctor’s primary board certification, with additional fees and testing, and half do not. The boards also are exploring annual or biannual check-ins or longitudinal assessments (for example, a question of the week sent to diplomats, who need to answer a certain percentage of the questions over a year). These more frequent assessments could better reflect the latest research in the field and rapid changes in medical practice.

AAHPM’s Chief Learning Officer Julie Bruno, MSW LCSW, works closely with leaders at the 10 specialty certifying boards and often relays the concerns of HPM practitioners. “We want to maintain the value of certification, but if you have people doing activities that aren’t relevant to their careers, it will turn them off and they may stop participating,” she said. “And we need to have as many actively certified HPM physicians recertified as possible—that is the key to retaining the workforce.”

“These are complex issues requiring a kind of balancing act,” said Joseph Rotella, MD MBA HMDC FAAHPM, the Academy’s chief medical officer. “On the one hand, it is important that we are recognized as a medical subspecialty in our own right. That will be even more important to retain a seat at the table where organized medicine defines healthcare reform. To be recognized as a subspecialty, we must have standards and competencies and all that these entail, including accredited fellowship programs. But if that makes it too hard to obtain or to retain certification, what does that mean to our workforce?”

Academy Leads Workforce Initiatives

“AAHPM defines workforce broadly,” Smith said. The Academy sees its role as helping qualified people find their way into the workforce and then keeping them engaged throughout their career. It also has undertaken research to better understand workforce needs and trends. “Attracting physicians to the field is only part of the challenge. We also need to retain as many practicing physicians as possible by supporting their learning, certification preparations, and professional resilience,” he said.

“We also are interested in alternative pathways and building bridges to primary care practitioners, who are—or should be—interested in developing primary/generalist palliative care skills. For example, we now have a Primary Care Special Interest Group within the Academy. This group and other committees are considering ways AAHPM can support this emerging and expanding group.”

Reflecting on the complexity of the issues and the varied inputs that contribute to the workforce and its adequacy, AAHPM has pursued workforce development and credentialing on a variety of fronts. For example, AAHPM has

  • collaborated with the George Washington University Health Workforce Institute to study the supply, distribution, need, and demand for HPM physicians.2 This includes surveys of new graduates of HPM fellowship programs about their experiences and attitudes, with plans to hold focus groups of physicians.
  • gathered case stories from members who contact the Academy seeking guidance on certification and wrote letters on their behalf to the various certification boards. The AAHPM Connect member online community also offers additional opportunities to discuss MOC issues.
  • sought and obtained grants to establish and support additional fellowships in HPM and published a fellowship funding guide.
  • recommended a team of AAHPM leaders to work with the National Board of Medical Examiners in reviewing palliative care content in the U.S. Medical Licensure Exam—and the need to better reflect in the exam basic palliative care concepts that should be part of the skill set of all licensed physicians.
  • advocated with the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) regarding the possibility of granting waivers from time-based fellowship requirements to foster innovation in graduate medical education.
  • participated for the past 5 years in the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) Liaison Committee on Certification and Recertification.
  • testified at the ABMS Visioning Commission, which is charged with helping enable the current MOC process to better demonstrate the profession’s commitment to professional self-regulation.
  • organized an MOC/Osteopathic Continuous Certification Advisory Group that has met with representatives from diverse certifying boards to monitor updates in MOC process and presented a half-day preconference workshop at the last Annual Assembly.
  • offered training opportunities, learning modules, and other resources for medical education and MOC-approved lifelong learning points for required educational activities by certified physicians.
  • empaneled a working group to develop Curricular Milestones and Entrustable Professional Activities for HPM fellowship training and assessment under ACGME’s Milestones system.
  • recommended a team of leaders to ACGME to update the reporting milestones for fellowship training to be HPM subspecialty specific.
  • advised ACGME, AOA, and the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine on their pursuit of a single graduate medical education system in the United States with common milestones and competencies.
  • continued to lead and advocate for passage of the Palliative Care and Hospice Education and Training Act, HR 1676, which was introduced into the 115th Congress by Rep. Eliot Engel (D-NY) as a step toward bringing more training opportunities to physicians in the field.

References

  1. Lupu D, Quigley L, Mehfoud N, Salsberg ES. The growing demand for hospice and palliative medicine physicians: will the supply keep up? J Pain Symptom Manage. 2018 April;55(4):1216–1223.
  2. Salsberg E, Mehfoud N, Quigley L, Lupu D; George Washington University Health Workforce Institute. A profile of active hospice and palliative medicine physicians, 2016. Retrieved from http://aahpm.org/uploads/AAHPM17_WorkforceStudy_July_2017_Profile_Final.pdf.

Larry Beresford is a freelance medical journalist in Oakland, CA, editor of the Hospice Compliance Letter newsletter published by Weatherbee Resources, and a contributor on end-of-life topics to the Lancet’s United States of Health U.S. blog page. Contact him at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .


Go to the table of contents to read more articles.

Essential Practices in Hospice and Palliative Medicine

This newly updated and rebranded comprehensive self-study provides a critical foundation for those who want to incorporate principles of hospice and palliative medicine into their daily lives.

Learn More

Quick Links

  • Job Mart
  • JPSM
  • CME/CE Certificates
  • Purchased Downloads
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

For Exhibitors and Advertisers

  • Commercial Support
  • Exhibiting and Advertising
  • Mailing Labels

For Students and Residents

  • Membership
  • Careers
  • Fellowships
  • Publications
Facebook Twitter Linked In Visit our patient website: PalliativeDoctors.org

AAHPM Logo

8735 West Higgins Road, Suite 300 Chicago, IL 60631

Phone 847-375-4712 Fax 847-375-6475 E-mail info@aahpm.org

Copyright © American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine